Another Bad Draw-Miscue-Scoop Foul Call in a Major Pro Pool Tournament

read OP rules link again:

Under the current rules (see WPA WSR 6.16c), a miscue is a foul only if it is intentional.

i have no doubt that marcel is right that cue hit cb multiple times, it was technically a foul, but an intention provision should overrule that

Here's the other pertinent rule:

2.11  MISCUE
A miscue occurs when the cue tip slides off the cue-ball possibly due to a contact that is too eccentric or due to insufficient chalk on the tip. It is usually accompanied by a sharp sound and evidenced by a discoloration of the tip. Although some miscues involve contact of the side of the cue-stick with the cue-ball, unless such contact is clearly visible, it is assumed not to have occurred. A scoop shot, in which the cue tip contacts the playing surface and the cue-ball at the same time, and this causes the cue-ball to rise off the cloth, is treated like a miscue. If an unintentional miscue causes the cue-ball to leave the playing surface, including partially or fully jumping over a ball, it is treated like a legal jump shot. Note that intentional miscues are covered by 3.16 Unsportsmanlike Conduct (c).

Another Bad Draw-Miscue-Scoop Foul Call in a Major Pro Pool Tournament

If it did hit the shaft and it was only obvious by video, is it a foul?

Yes, assuming the video is reviewed.

Should video review be allowed for miscues?

... only if the ref thinks there is a strong reason to do so.

With technology, if this is allowed then all miscues will soon be fouls.

Nope, unless the rules are changed and super-slow-motion filming of every shot with expensive high-speed-video cameras becomes common-place. I don't see that happening anytime soon. The frame rate of regular video cameras is not fast enough to catch possible secondary contact with during typical miscue and scoop shots.

QATAR WORLD CUP 10 BALL, OCT. 28 to NOV. 2, 2025

good player but it's gonna take years re-build integrity and trust, especially living in the internet age
If I am not mistaken, Amoroto was the next big Filipino phenom M was promoting while Manas was still in diapers.
Now M is belatedly promoting arguably the most famous pool player on social media 16 year old JB. Not as talented as AJ in pool but a natural entertainer, charismatic not boring like Manas :LOL:


jb.PNG

QATAR WORLD CUP 10 BALL, OCT. 28 to NOV. 2, 2025

Draw for Stage 2 (main event). Starts tomorrow 28 Oct. All times Qatar time 7 hrs ahead of Eastern

Brackets
https://qbsf.qa/ui/events/details?e...a0b-4450-b41e-08ddb95efe38&activeTab=brackets

Matches
https://qbsf.qa/ui/events/details?e...7a0b-4450-b41e-08ddb95efe38&activeTab=matches

Live Scores
https://qbsf.qa/ui/events/details?e...-4450-b41e-08ddb95efe38&activeTab=live-scores

Youtube stream

Filter

Back
Top