Net deflection (the combination of squirt and swerve, AKA squerve) varies a lot with shot speed and distance, cue elevation, conditions, and the amount and type of spin and English. You can certainly make BHE "work" for any bridge length provided you have good understanding or "feel" for all of the effects, and provided you adjust the right things the right amounts for the right shots. Good players (like it sounds like you are) can do this instinctively, based on lots of practice and experience (i.e., lots of missed shots in the past).
Regards,
Dave
Dave,
This is where I respectfully disagree with you. I understand the point about "squerve" variance with conditions and all. But in practice, as Dave has said many many times and as I also say, we approach every shot the same way. We aim it the same, we apply BHE the same and sometimes our bridge is long and sometimes it's short and we don't adjust based on that.
In my video I show you shots where I am bridging a half cue stick away from the cue ball.
I promise you that prior to making that little video I NEVER EVER attempted to make a shot like that with that long of a bridge. That's what bridge sticks are for.
I also don't normally get within a few inches of the cue ball with my bridge hand but I did for the purpose of the video.
I am certain that the results I had can be duplicated on just about any table with no change in my approach to the shot.
In this case there was no instinct based on missed shots to go on.
I submit that "instinct" is way overrated in pool. If a player is fortunate enough to be able to see and drop in on the right line without learning any particular aiming system then they are very lucky and hopefully they can master all the other aspects that go with aiming to reach championship level.
I was one of those people who had plenty of "missed ball" training - I was a member or the million balls club and still had trouble with a lot of shots. After learning Hal's Quarters System (my name for it) my game went up two balls over night. Those trouble shots vanished in one week.
While I agree that experience hones instinct experience alone cannot replace bad mechanics. I had plenty of battle hardened experience playing pool and practicing pool. What I didn't have was the ability to get on the right line every time. So I could have hit two million more balls and still been highly inconsistent in my pocketing, especially with the thin cuts and seemingly impossible shots.
Using a system that puts me on the right line coupled with BHE has elevated my game tremendously. I routinely make shots that are considered tough and low percentage, and really they were super low percentage ones for me. As for thinking about my bridge length and the pivot point of my cue and the speed of the shot as relates to how much deflection will be there - I don't.
And it's not because my instincts have been honed from missing a bunch of balls in the past.
It's because I have a repeatable and reliable way to aim and apply spin that works and allows me to treat each shot as almost exactly the same.