That's exactly the way it worked! They had four guys visit my poolroom on four occasions and each of them sued for $16,000 (four times $4,000), for a total of $64,000! They tried to settle early on at a mediation conference for $32,000 and we refused, preferring instead to go to trial, which is not what they want to happen. The day before the trial they messaged my attorney and asked for $16,000 to settle. I could either settle or pay my attorney $6,000 to fight it, unsure about the outcome. I gambled on my attorney who told me he had a plan.
My attorney was a triple smart guy and tripped up all four of the plaintiffs on cross examination. They couldn't remember what they ordered (food and drinks) while they were there, and we had all the receipts. They couldn't remember much of anything about their four visits to my poolroom. And when my attorney laid the bombshell on the judge about all the similar filings these same guys had made up and down the West Coast and Southwest (he read off a list of over one hundred cases) until the judge said, "That's enough! I get the picture."
The court went into recess after that for lunch and the judge said he would have his decision later that day. Two hours later he called us all back into the courtroom. He laid into the scamming lawyer behind all this and told him if he ever sees him in court again, he's going to jail for filing frivolous lawsuits. He added that he will inform all the courts in Los Angeles County to look out for him. Then he ruled in our favor 100% and made the guy pay the court costs of several hundred dollars. My attorney asked for reasonable attorney fees but the judge denied that. I had to pay him $6,000, but it was worth it for a job well done.
Outside the courtroom, the four paid assholes who tried to pull this stunt on me were congregated together with the lawyer. They got nothing for their efforts and looked pretty unhappy. I couldn't help myself and walked by them and said (loudly), "Have a nice day.....assholes!" No one said boo to me. I would have liked it if one of them had approached me. I was extremely pissed at the time and would have probably gone for the throat. Yes, I did feel a degree of hatred for all of them at that moment. They put me through months of aggravation and thousands of dollars defending myself and my poolroom. :angry:
P.S. The bottom line is that Murphy (the owner of the poolroom) should hire an attorney and fight these guys in court. That's his best chance to prevail and save his business..