Is Joshua Filler the best pool player?

Not sure if you were responding directly to me, or just agreeing with me. But yes, I agree with your succinct assessment. I'm taking Filler even money.

About the only person-game I might consider betting on someone else would be Filler-Gorst 10b. And even then I'm not sure.
👍 I'll take Filler. That was for everybody
 
If you split out a two-year stretch, and one of the years was weaker for Filler relative to the field, the other year would be stronger. I think the trend is pretty clear. (And with nine separate yearly analyses, people's eyes would glaze over.)
I think if he was the highest in each of the nine years, it would have been presented that way.
 
Joshua is 29 years old. Here's a look at his performance over the last nine years.

Please keep doing these types of video, really interesting. Thanks a lot.

I still remember back in 2017/2018, Filler played Chua in a money game, and Chua spotted Filler two balls (either the 7 playing 9-ball or the 8 playing 10-ball, can't remember exactly). I don't think Filler won that match, either.

Back then, hardly anyone here knew who Chua was. Most people only knew Orcollo and Biado.

Two things come to mind:
  1. Filler has taken his game to another level. In this 2020s era, he's simply too far ahead of most of the competition.
  2. There's always someone in the Philippines who plays better than you. We just haven't learned their name yet. 😂
 
Wonder if Filler and Shane has ever discussed a race to 100. That’s Shane’s game. Would Filler play it. I think he should

And to add when during Covid and Filler was at Roy’s basement playing constantly he put on quite a display
We're a few years past where a Filler-SVB match up would actually be compelling. SVB is inching downward and, at 43, his stamina, always his hallmark, just can't match a 20-something's energy.

SVB could win a race to 20. To 120? Not a chance.
 
In men's pool, I think we've reached the point where asking who is best is silly.

This year, Josh has won four majors. Let's call a major a field having 96+ players, a deep internationally diverse field, and $25,000+ first prize. In 2026, Josh has won the Las Vegas Open, UK Open, Bali, Qatar). He also won the Derby 9ball and got bronze at both the World 10ball and the WNT European Open. Four titles and six medals at the majors in a single year is almost unfathomable given the depth of the fields now found at the majors. He is playing pool at a level never seen before and, frankly, beyond anything I thought I would ever see in my lifetime. Restricting my attentions to singles play at the WNT and Predator PBS tours, nobody but Josh has won even two majors this year.

Asking whether Filler is the best ever is a little more reasonable. If I'm momentarily allowed to omit Mosconi and Greenleaf, I've already got Josh as a top three pool player of all time, with Efren and Sigel the only two others worthy of mention. For example, Josh, still 29, already owns a better career resume than the 43-year-old SVB by quite a bit. As I noted in another thread:

At 29, Josh has won more majors than Shane did in his entire career. Shane is, notably, missing the China Open (every bit as hard to win as the US Open 9ball until recently, possibly harder) and is missing nearly all of the ten ball majors (most notably the Las Vegas Open, Bali Open, Qatar Open, World 10ball). Josh has won the gold medal at the World Games and Shane has not. Each has a World 9ball and a World 8ball, but Shane has just one WNT major outside of the World 9ball (Florida Open) while Josh has three (2 UK Opens and 1 European Open). Josh has won the WPA World Teams Championship 10ball and Shane has not. Whether you look at the 9ball majors or the 10ball majors, Josh has outshone Shane by quite a bit.

Shane's five US Open 9balls is awesome, legendary indeed, but so is Filler's 1 US Open, 3 China Opens and 1 World Games gold. To that point of the comparison, there's a discussion, but Josh has also won major championships all over the globe on a very regular basis and Shane has not. That's why Shane is missing so many of the majors on his resume and Josh is not.

I think it's too early to place Josh above Sigel or Efren, but he's the best of the 21st century and I think he'll, one day, be remembered as the best pool player of all time. Yes, he has the highest ever Fargo, but greatness is measured in titles, specifically major titles, and no player of this century measures up to Josh Filler.

Filler has been in dead stroke for a decade!
Genuine question - not being snarky, but how many of those majors existed with consistency when SVB was in his 20's?
Yes filler has a Qatar 10 ball, but a Qatar 10 ball didn't exist until shane was in his 40's.
I don't think a flat # of titles is valid assessment when the game and the number of opportunities available has changed so much. A ratio of majors won vs majors available would be more appropriate.
 
Fedor did beat Filler in the final of the World Pool Masters that year (hill hill).
Yes, I remember it. Might have been the best match of the entire year and the shot that made the difference at double hill was one of the better position shots I have ever seen, with Gorst going three rails of the one ball to find the short side of the two.
 
don't think i quite follow here. is this referring to the fargo included players currently playing chinese pool, like ko ping chung?

I'm saying that in general, when you look at pool players across the globe, many thousands of games/matches are unreported, especially throughout Asia. Factor those unknowns in, and Filler may not be outperforming everyone they way fargo suggests.

This only shows how dominate Filler is according to fargo rated events.
 
Genuine question - not being snarky, but how many of those majors existed with consistency when SVB was in his 20's?
Yes filler has a Qatar 10 ball, but a Qatar 10 ball didn't exist until shane was in his 40's.
I don't think a flat # of titles is valid assessment when the game and the number of opportunities available has changed so much. A ratio of majors won vs majors available would be more appropriate.
Well said, The majors change with time and there are more of them now. Mosconi and Greenleaf have major titles that neither Shane nor Josh will likely never win.

Count me among the many that feels Shane is playing the best pool of his life right now and has a better chance to win today's majors than the Shane of yesteryear (that won most of his big titles on 4 1/2" pockets and with break from the kitchen) would have had.

Yes, the timing is always a tricky matter. When he was in his 20s, and a review of old threads would validate this, the majors were the World 9ball, the US Open 9ball, the China Open and the All-Japan. Just one of them, the US Open 9ball, was played on American soil. From 2004-2021, the only one of these that Shane won was the US Open 9ball, though he did it five times.. His track record was very disappointing at the overseas majors, even though he played the China Open and All-Japan every year. Finally, he won the world 9ball at age 39 in Poland. If you were around then, you remember all of this. In short, any suggestion that Shane in his 20s was mass producing majors other than the ones he won in America against chiefly American fields does not hold up to scrutiny.

I think the comparison of Filler vs Shane would be very lopsided in Filler's favor if you calculated the percentage of majors won. Number of majors played career-to-date would, of course, be much, much higher in the case of Shane.

Only one of these two has mass produced majors all over the world for the length of his career. As you suggest, though, the comparison is made difficult by the viral globalization of the game in the past ten years, which has given us more majors, but also fields that are the most competitive we have ever seen in our sport. That's why nobody but Josh has won more than one major this year at the WNT and Predator events.

Both Shane and Josh are immortals in our sport but, as Jay Helfert has noted, one seems to always get it done in the biggest spots when the most money is riding on the outcome. In a way that brings back memories of Efren and Sigel, Filler loses awfully few finals. Contrastingly, for much of his career, at the overseas majors, Shane couldn't get by Ko Pin Yi, Wu Jiaqing, Albin Ouschan or Darren Appleton in overseas majors in the biggest moments.

Your post is important, highlighting the incredible difficulty of comparison across generations of players. Here on the forum, we do it because we enjoy it, but we all understand that it is a very inexact science. Even so, we must not lose sight of the point you have made.
 
He’s heading there but it takes decades of being at the top like svb … but he’s at the top of the conversation
Yup, on a longevity basis, I doubt Filler, or Gorst for that matter, will still be winning majors at the age of 43. Still, if you think Shane ever enjoyed a ten-year span of play that even nearly matches the first ten years of Filler's career, your memory is failing you.

And, no, Shane was not at the top for decades. His years of being at or near the top were 2007-14. In fact, 2014 was the last time that Shane was the Billiards Digest Player of the Year. From 2015-21, he was consistently among the elite, but his performance at the majors, both at home and overseas, was disappointing. In 2022, he found his best game again, memorably winning the World 9ball but, in my opinion, at no point in this decade was Shane the world's best player.

I don't enjoy writing posts like this one, and some of the most ardent American fans are sure to hate on me (I've gotten used to it). Still, as a 51 year fan of the game that has regularly traveled to tournaments since the 1970s, I've seen up close the careers of all the greats since Sigel, and nobody (possibly excepting Wu Jiaqing, whose career was short) has ever wowed me like Filler, whose sustained excellence year after year after year in the biggest spots is almost unfathomable.
 
I think if he was the highest in each of the nine years, it would have been presented that way.

I didn't know Filler would be at the top of all the time periods when I made the choice.

I think I was more motivated by getting enough games for some of the top Asian players and also spanning the covid period. Given that in the earlier periods he was only ahead by a point or so, you're likely right he wouldn't be ahead every individual year--though I don't know that.
 
[...]

It’s just hard for me to accept that during the time that Fedor was getting the “Gorst Slam” he wasn’t the best on the planet. Same for FSR during his purple patch. If you are winning the US Open, World 9b etc and Filler *isn’t* winning majors, that means something to me, no matter how much Filler dominates lesser tournaments. It doesn’t mean Filler wasn’t the highest Fargo in that period, but I personally wouldn’t say he was the best.”

Some of the lesser tournaments Filler won during the Gorst Slam year, 2024, are
China Open,
World 8-Ball Championship,
DCC 9-Ball,
DCC Banks,
DCC Bigfoot

and don't forget the Challenge of Champions, where World 8-Ball, 9-Ball, and 10-Ball champions (Filler, Gorst, Biado) battled it out and Filler won.

And Filler was a single rack away from winning World Pool Masters

Regardless, who won more or more significant of these largely single elimination events is a pretty noisy measuring stick
 
In men's pool, I think we've reached the point where asking who is best is silly.

This year, Josh has won four majors. Let's call a major a field having 96+ players, a deep internationally diverse field, and $25,000+ first prize. In 2026, Josh has won the Las Vegas Open, UK Open, Bali, Qatar). He also won the Derby 9ball and got bronze at both the World 10ball and the WNT European Open. Four titles and six medals at the majors in a single year is almost unfathomable given the depth of the fields now found at the majors. He is playing pool at a level never seen before and, frankly, beyond anything I thought I would ever see in my lifetime. Restricting my attentions to singles play at the WNT and Predator PBS tours, nobody but Josh has won even two majors this year.

Asking whether Filler is the best ever is a little more reasonable. If I'm momentarily allowed to omit Mosconi and Greenleaf, I've already got Josh as a top three pool player of all time, with Efren and Sigel the only two others worthy of mention. For example, Josh, still 29, already owns a better career resume than the 43-year-old SVB by quite a bit. As I noted in another thread:

At 29, Josh has won more majors than Shane did in his entire career. Shane is, notably, missing the China Open (every bit as hard to win as the US Open 9ball until recently, possibly harder) and is missing nearly all of the ten ball majors (most notably the Las Vegas Open, Bali Open, Qatar Open, World 10ball). Josh has won the gold medal at the World Games and Shane has not. Each has a World 9ball and a World 8ball, but Shane has just one WNT major outside of the World 9ball (Florida Open) while Josh has three (2 UK Opens and 1 European Open). Josh has won the WPA World Teams Championship 10ball and Shane has not. Whether you look at the 9ball majors or the 10ball majors, Josh has outshone Shane by quite a bit.

Shane's five US Open 9balls is awesome, legendary indeed, but so is Filler's 1 US Open, 3 China Opens and 1 World Games gold. To that point of the comparison, there's a discussion, but Josh has also won major championships all over the globe on a very regular basis and Shane has not. That's why Shane is missing so many of the majors on his resume and Josh is not.

I think it's too early to place Josh above Sigel or Efren, but he's the best of the 21st century and I think he'll, one day, be remembered as the best pool player of all time. Yes, he has the highest ever Fargo, but greatness is measured in titles, specifically major titles, and no player of this century measures up to Josh Filler.

Filler has been in dead stroke for a decade!
BULLSHIT, is he the best player right now, absolutely, does he have a better career than SVB, nope. not yet.
 
Back
Top