We just called him "Kelly" and everyone knew who you were talking about. I first fell in love with pool after watching "The Hustler" in 1961. The second time was when I saw Kelly play. It was like he had elevated pool to an art form. His movements around the table were so graceful, and the way he got down on the ball and delivered his stroke were equally as beautiful. Those who saw him play will know exactly what I'm talking about. I wanted to be like him and just glide around the table, making everything look so simple and magnificent at the same time.
He was just as comfortable playing in a tux in a grand ballroom as he was playing in a backroom somewhere and betting all his cheese. Kelly was widely recognized as the best All Around player in the game for many years. This was the premier distinction in the pool world at that time, before there was much formal recognition of pool brilliance. He always dressed to the nines, with flared bell bottoms, alligator shoes and a long collared shirt. He would carry the best case and play with the nicest looking cue. He usually drove a new Caddy as well. Kelly was the movie star of the pool world and could back it up on the table.
Eddie was the inspiration for John Brescia to write the movie The Baltimore Bullet. It was his story dramatized for the big screen. James Coburn played his part in the movie. His last big match was in the finals of Grady's World One Pocket Championship at the Flamingo Hilton in Reno in 1992. There were over 100 of the best One Pocket players in the world there and it ended up with Kelly and Cornbread Red in the finals. They both played brilliantly, harking back to their old rivalry. The first prize was $20,000, a very large payday back then. Fittingly, it went down to the last ball, tied three games apiece and 7-7. After a series of well executed safeties, Kelly got an opening and banked the final ball into his hole for the win. Too bad there wasn't any video of that match. I wrote a long article about it for Billiards Digest but it got edited down to one page.