Rubyron's design looks good if only he could change the rail color to brown, and the letters to yellow. Should use a darker green in the background (felt or cloth) but.....
My personal choice would be similiar to the one I submitted. Brown rails, black background, and yellow letters. With the "member tag" included, and replacing "the A to Z of Billiards and Pool." to read "The Pool & Billiards Internet Forum."
My reasoning for the change is that if the keychaing gets lost, anyone who does not know what AZ Billiards stands for would be able to know that it belongs to someone that is member of an Internet Forum.
The words "A to Z of Billiards and Pool" does not get this message across.
Just my honest opinion..