not being condescending -- just sayin' when i miscue, i know it's my stroke, i'm not blaming it on my tip not being scuffed.
i saw Ralf Souquet scuff his tip once after a miscue. other than that, i don't recall seeing a pro scuff a tip, and i've seen a lot of pro pool with a reasonable dose of miscues.
maybe there are tips that need scuffing. i've only used Triangles, Moori, Everest, Elkmasters, and Precision (Dennis Searing). none of those have ever needed it, but i can believe that there might be some that do.
but for the most part, i believe that scuffers are just one more gadget to distract from the honest work of developing a good stroke.
I 100% believe what you say is how you feel. However, is it fair to project your experience on others, assuming that their experience must mirror your own, or that they'll take away the same thing from similar experiences. Ralf Souquet is about as robotic and meticulous as any player I have ever seen. If he miscues, his stroke would be at the bottom of my list of suspected reasons. The fact that he immediately redressed his tip indicates that he likely suspected contamination, and wished to create a new surface. By contamination I mean oils, grime, moisture, etc. on the tip that could hinder friction.
You believe scuffers are just one more gadget to distract from the honest work of developing a good stroke. Do you feel that applies to Souquet? I don't. Rather I believe he knew exactly what was going on & had the experience and knowledge to address the issue. Do you believe the other top players who didn't scuff their tip immediately didn't scuff it after the match, or even have a new tip installed? Ask Joe Blackburn or Steve Lomax how many tips they have installed for pro players at major events because they just miscued.