I think we would all do well to at least consider the fact that Earl may have a mental condition, such as manic/depression, etc.. He almost certainly is obsessive/compulsive.
The man may actually find it extremely hard to control himself. At least he is still able to function in society to some degree, which is more than a lot of people with mental illness can say.
As evidenced by Howard Hughes, Steve Nash, et. al., you can be completely nuts and still be successful. I say as long as he isn't stabbing players with his pool cue, we might give him the benefit of the doubt.
If the promotor/tournament officials warn Earl before the tournament on what is acceptable behavior, and Earl violates the rules, then by all means, throw him out.
Let's keep in mind, though.. There are a LOT of fans who like watching Earl, win or lose, and I would bet that a lot of people are watching his matches hoping to catch the leding edge of an Earl comeback to the level we all know he could still play.
Earl still has the talent to dominate like he did in the 90's.. He just doesn't have the mental game. I feel bad for Earl, because it looks like he might be starting that downward slde into serious mental illness.
If Earl becomes incapable of playing high level pool, what is he going to do? It's been his all consuming passion since he was a teen. It's not good when a manic/depressive, obsessive/compulsive loses his or her reason for living....
Russ
Russ