For the record (and I knew Fat's damn well), the man could play! He was what we might call today a low level A player. No question the top players could give him a small spot, but not much. His best games were Banks (Very strong, solid A speed), One Pocket (moved good and banked great) and Three Cushions (deceptively strong). I watched him beat Eddie Robins (who denies the match took place) in Detroit when Eddie was the rising young star of Three Cushion billiards. It was a Race to 50 for $500 and Fats trailed all the way until the end, when he ran eight and out from 49-42! The man had HEART!
He also trimmed Richie Florence for a telephone number getting 8-7 at One Hole in Johnston City. They played $300 a game (big money then) and Fats beat Richie for two to three thousand a day (they didn't play every day) over a period of two weeks. I saw parts of it and Fats looked like the favorite to me. In fact during the time I was around Fats, every time I heard about him being in action, he took it down. And that is the bottom line after all, who won the money. That's how we kept score back then!
San Jose Dick is another story, He was a solid A player, one of the few who could hold his own against Ronnie, who was the greatest in my book. Dick would have had to give Fats 8-7 imo. Of course giving Fats 8-7 was a dangerous proposition. The man shot those super hard, back-cut cross corner banks better than anyone I ever saw, including Ronnie. Like the cue ball is in front of your pocket and the object ball is on the second diamond across from you. Fats cut-banked that ball back into his pocket with regularity and played shape!
I bet that even made tricky Dicky a little wide eyed!
Dick is right, Fats had that gift for gab that made him that much tougher to beat. Ronnie also had that same gift, where he could totally distract his opponent. By the way, Ronnie never bragged about his game (or his speed). It was bad for business. He was no dummy! If you asked Ronnie he always rated everyone else higher than where they should have been. Ronnie, like Fats, was triple smart when it came to matching up.