New Southwest or Franklin?

gmcole

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Is a franklin any different than a new southwest? I mean ONLY as far as playability, not investment. If so please explain. I will look at buying as soon as I decide what to look for.
thanks-jeff
 
Jeff,

Despite what many might say, I firmly believe that the quality is the same. In fact, many would argue that they have improved with time (years of practice). Of course you will have many that feel the Franklins where the way to go. I've hit with old and new, and some of each "hit" better than others to me. Who knows...different combinations of woods, ferrules, shaft tapers??

A friend of mine has a huge collection of Runde's, they all have a slightly different feel to them. I think the same for SW. While I am a huge fan of their cues, I have never felt comfortable with their standard taper. They offer three to my knowlege. All three tapers would give you a different "feel".

my 2 cents.

Doug
 
Salamander said:
Jeff,

Despite what many might say, I firmly believe that the quality is the same. In fact, many would argue that they have improved with time (years of practice). Of course you will have many that feel the Franklins where the way to go. I've hit with old and new, and some of each "hit" better than others to me. Who knows...different combinations of woods, ferrules, shaft tapers??

A friend of mine has a huge collection of Runde's, they all have a slightly different feel to them. I think the same for SW. While I am a huge fan of their cues, I have never felt comfortable with their standard taper. They offer three to my knowlege. All three tapers would give you a different "feel".

my 2 cents.

Doug
thanks- how do you tell which taper, are they numbered? Did the franklins have three as well? thanks-jeff
 
tapes

gmcole said:
thanks- how do you tell which taper, are they numbered? Did the franklins have three as well? thanks-jeff
was thinking the same thing as I have heard that the new southwest have 3 taper options?
 
gmcole said:
thanks- how do you tell which taper, are they numbered? Did the franklins have three as well? thanks-jeff

There current tapers are "standard", "standard pro", and pro. The standard is what I believe many people refer to as the "conical taper". In other words it grows quickly from the ferrule onward. The "stadard pro" is somewhat pro tapered, but still grows fairly fast. I don't know too much about their pro taper. If you email Laurie, she would be more that glad to tell you the difference.

As far as early Franklin SW's, I do not know what tapers they used then. Keep in mind, that after years of use, many Franklins do not resemble their original taper, or they might have been retapered in the past. Again, ask Laurie.

I really feel that the taper of the shaft is the most telling part of how the cue plays to you. The craftmanship is the same. The "hit", will very much be contingent on the taper, and to some extent, the ferrule and tip and woods used.

Regards,

Doug
 
Last edited:
On a side note, as a fellow forum member indicated to me. He had a "standard" taper, that he had retapered to "stadard pro", and he indicated that it made a world of difference to him in the playability of the cue. Remember, this is just one man's opinion. He felt there was too much cue ball deflection with the "standard" shaft. I tend to agree. However, the "standard" shaft sure feels solid. To each his own....
 
Well...

I have played with several SW cues. I currently own 2 of them and I will add this.

I have never played with a JF era cue that didnt play pretty well. I have played with some new Southwest cues that didnt play well. What does that mean? Possibly nothing, because I could have played with the "best" of the older ones, and some of the worst "new" ones, maybe, you read into that whatever makes sense for you.

The JF era Southwest cue that I own, has 2 orignal shafts each weighing in at 3.2 oz. I asked Laurie to make me a heavy shaft or one that was my normal 4.0 oz. I paid a huge amount for the shaft, IMO, and I had to personally make sure they got as heavy as possible on shaft, and that took some convincing.

It plays best with the heavier shaft, and I would prefer it the cue was a little lighter, as it is a ebony nosed cue and with the heavy shaft it is over 20 oz., and I prefer my cues in the 19.0 -19.5 range.

More than what you asked for, but good luck.

Ken
 
gmcole said:
Is a franklin any different than a new southwest? I mean ONLY as far as playability, not investment. If so please explain. I will look at buying as soon as I decide what to look for.
thanks-jeff

I haven't tried pau ferro, ebony.

But I have played with goncale, purple, cocobolo, maple nose. IMO purpleheart nose SW has the best hit.
 
gmcole said:
Is a franklin any different than a new southwest? I mean ONLY as far as playability, not investment. If so please explain. I will look at buying as soon as I decide what to look for.
thanks-jeff

Simple answer.

Do two persons have the same handwriting?
 
I've had like 30 Sw cues most of them were JF.
The JF hit better in my opinion,although I've had some new ones as great hitters.

IMO the new shaft wood deflexs more....

My 2 cents

Vass
 
I've had 15 SW's. Of those I've had about 4 Franklins and they all hit very crisply and were much to my liking. Of the other 11 only a couple played as well, imo, as the Franklins but those two or three had a hit every bit as strong as those made in Jerry's era.

You'll not be able to pick your cue according to when it was made or what material it is made of. You'll have to find a way to play with as many as you can until you find one that just knocks your socks off.
 
I have to say there is no difference at all,the same standards,same style,same quality control,same demanding exact selection of woods by the same Franklin as before.
I knew the Franklins very well,they came to our place,we shopped for wood together,and it was Lori who went through piece after piece,selecting or rejecting the wood,Ihave been there since Jerry passed away and seen Lori going through a big stack of wood carefully selecting.
In the last few years of Jerry's career he was almost exclusively doing the wraps and finish.Mickey,Al and Lori were doing everything else.These same people are doing exactly the same thing.How could there be any difference?I liked the standard taper then and still prefer it today,but some people prefer the other,choices were available then as well as now.

I have owned dozens of the cues over a period of 20 years and I would bet the farm that no one can tell the difference from outward appearance and playability.

If you find one buy it,if you don't mind a 9 year waiting list then order a new one.
Call Lori at 702 870 9615,or ask for Vince Tedesco's phone number and buy one from him,he usually has new ones.Either way you will not be disappointed.

DEAN
 
I agree totally with Dean...I have owned at least 20 Southwest cues and have personally spoken with Laurie Franklin on this subject. She said for the last two years Jerry was only doing the finish on the cues. The quality if anything is better today, however for investment purposes obviously a Jerry era cue is more valuable. But for pure playability it shouldn't matter. If your main objective is to find a cue to play with then I would recommend going with a post Jerry era cue and save yourself some money. While no two baseball bats feel the same, you can still hit homeruns with either...and the same will hold true in Southwest cues. IMO they play great and I play with one now and have a new one coming within the next couple of months. The one I'm playing with will be for sale shortly, so if you're interested send me a PM...Thanks and good luck
 
Good info Dean, and I'll add that in some cases SW is still working with wood bought when Jerry was working. Only small difference between long ago and today are the ferrules--older Frankilns had Micarta ferrules and today's cues have LBM. The SW crew continue to maintain high focus on quality. Anywho, the mystique about the Franklin era cues is mostly harmless and will continue on no matter what! Since I like shafts close to 13mm, I highly prefer the standard pro taper. I'd guesstimate that 95% or more of SW cues have the standard taper. Martin


deanoc said:
I have to say there is no difference at all,the same standards,same style,same quality control,same demanding exact selection of woods by the same Franklin as before.
I knew the Franklins very well,they came to our place,we shopped for wood together,and it was Lori who went through piece after piece,selecting or rejecting the wood,Ihave been there since Jerry passed away and seen Lori going through a big stack of wood carefully selecting.
In the last few years of Jerry's career he was almost exclusively doing the wraps and finish.Mickey,Al and Lori were doing everything else.These same people are doing exactly the same thing.How could there be any difference?I liked the standard taper then and still prefer it today,but some people prefer the other,choices were available then as well as now.

I have owned dozens of the cues over a period of 20 years and I would bet the farm that no one can tell the difference from outward appearance and playability.

If you find one buy it,if you don't mind a 9 year waiting list then order a new one.
Call Lori at 702 870 9615,or ask for Vince Tedesco's phone number and buy one from him,he usually has new ones.Either way you will not be disappointed.

DEAN
 
Ken_4fun said:
I have played with several SW cues. I currently own 2 of them and I will add this.

I have never played with a JF era cue that didnt play pretty well. I have played with some new Southwest cues that didnt play well. What does that mean? Possibly nothing, because I could have played with the "best" of the older ones, and some of the worst "new" ones, maybe, you read into that whatever makes sense for you.

Ken

Ken, I think a lot of people have run into the same "accidental" situation as you, including myself. I've had three Franklin-era South Wests and all hit very similar, and lights-out. I've only played with one new South West, but I didn't like it at all. I'm not inclined to spend additional money further testing new South Wests - just doesn't make sense, given how well the three Franklin-era's played.
 
My Cue

I've had four southwest cues, an '03 6 point ebony with maple nose, a 59 inch '01 with cocobolo nose, an all birdseye Franklin (no points), and my current player (in my avatar) a Franklin with Alves forearm and butt sleeve with birdseye points, no veneers. My current player is the best of the four.
 
Sneakypete05 said:
I've had four southwest cues, an '03 6 point ebony with maple nose, a 59 inch '01 with cocobolo nose, an all birdseye Franklin (no points), and my current player (in my avatar) a Franklin with Alves forearm and butt sleeve with birdseye points, no veneers. My current player is the best of the four.

I also had a Franklin-era SW with alves forearm and birdseye points, no veneers - one of the best-playing cues I ever owned.
 

Attachments

  • DSC01178.jpg
    DSC01178.jpg
    26.1 KB · Views: 191
Back
Top