Petey, David mentioned starting a new thread so he doesn't derail this one. Pretty good of him to offer.
Or maybe, it is all against their vows or other excuse
Do I denote a slight amount of sarchasm there Dave.
I'm sure that they don't take sacred vows. Maybe just an unwritten or taught understanding on how they conduct themselves, maybe in all aspects of life. After all, isn't that what martial Arts is about. Martial Arts Golden Rule and such.
Shaolin Monks. I'm pretty sure that they can handle themselves fairly well. Yet, you don't see them hanging around bars picking fights over the bar box.
The video that Shark linked was new to me and I would have to say, one of the best demonstrations that I have watched. Sure, the attacker comes slow. Watch any Martial Arts demo of any discipline and they all do the same.
But, speed up the attack and the response becomes faster as well. The faster the response, the possibility of injury becomes more and they probably don't want for that to happen.
I watched 2 Aikido vs MMA and one vs Muay Thai.
To be honest, I would have to say that I was expecting more ( a little disappointed) from the one (older) Aikido fighter. The second, vs Muay Thai, both Russian and the Aikido fared much better.
In all honesty, it did seem that all of those locks and moves were lost in the battle somehow. Still, I have witnessed it, well my elbows,wrists and shoulders did anyway so not going to budge much on my opinion of Aikido.
In both fights, once the Aikido was down and grappling, it appeared that they the upper hand.
Hey, when a farmer puts one of his dairy cows in a stall to get milk, is that a form of Mooey Tie.
I also would say that I have seen Kick Boxing live and always figured that it was pretty effective. Watching the Muay Thai and some of the others, I think it would rank as at least one of the best.
In that I mean, if you watch the graceful Katas of Kung Fu and some of the other Arts,
and then watch them in a fight situation, many of the moves seem to go out the window.
One thing to practice in a dojo and another to do it in a ring or the street.
So, that is why I believe that Muay Thai and similar arts are some of the most effective in real life situations. Its basic and raw at the dojo and doesn't have to differ on the street. What you see is what you get.
Not much difference watching MMA fighters in the ring or in a street fight.
Yeah, my brother wasn't overly impressed with Segal. Like I mentioned, he had a dojo in Japan, brought it over. Some of the traditional Masters didn't care for that much or the way it was presented and the way Steven did it. Maybe the way he presents Aikido in his movies. They feel that he has disrespected the Art. Made a bit of a mockery of it. Thats why he is in a certain amount of disfavor.
Yet, he is a Sheehan, a teachers teacher, and that didn't come from putting a quarter in a vending machine. So, no matter what peoples opinion may be, he still can be a bad a ss.
If you watch some of his demos, he is very effective but seems to lack a certain amount of finesse that you see in others. As in, the younger Master in the link that Shark provided for one.
When you watched the old cage fighters, when Gracey was involved, it was fairly boring. A few punches and kicks were presented and as soon as Gracey got them down, it was 30 minutes of grappling with Gracey having his opponents face in a scissor lock and their face in his crotch.
Could only take so much of that. It has improved a serious amount since then.