Parica's name would be on the list of the ten best pool players I ever saw. So would Efren, Dennis O. Buddy, Sigel, Mizerak and Earl are up there too. Among the old times Lassiter and Worst stand out. There were many other equal or near equal greats that are not so well known like Marvin Henderson, Greg Stevens and Billy Johnson/Wade Crane. Our own Keith belongs in a special category of one! None of the above were as smooth as him, and only Rafael was his equal at making circus shots.
Today's game is a completely different era! Guys like Filler, Gorst et al may just be better than any of the above players, but the equipment has something to do with that. That said, prime years Earl (9-Ball) or Mizerak (14.1), Dennis (they know that), Buddy would have definitely challenged these guys. Again Harold Worst is a special case. I'm confident he could raise his game to any level required to be a winner. He had something inside that is rare in any sport, kind of like a Tom Brady or Patrick Mahommes who will refuse to lose!
We have both seen so many amazing players over the years. I only saw videos of Lassiter and he was older, never seen anything with Worst playing.
I agree with just about everything you say, I do feel the need to toss Rags name in the mix because my buddy George spoke so reverently of him , and he was not big on compliments, I wish I could have seen him play. George told me he was enough better than everyone else that it wasn't even a question among other players.
Also the Mysterious Phillipino guy who was a legend over there but couldn't get in the US. I can't remember his name, he must have been something else. .
I believe like you, that the equipment changes were so big that they changed the dynamics of the games , It is still a ball going in a hole though, and I am as sure as I can be that guys like Orcollo Filler and Gorst and others ,would have been just as good in 1965, as they are today.
My big question is how the players of the 20th century would have done on this new equipment, Some of those guys, Sigel comes to mind , used the whole pocket and about a foot of the rail to make balls . You can forget that today, The pockets are smaller the shelfs cut deeper, I think some of those olden guys would have had a terrible time on this new equipment. I have to give Earl Strickland a lot of credit, he had so many things against him with the equipment and father time and he still plays at a high level. He's number 8 of all US players, that's amazing!
I picked Efren based on many things, most of all , his dominance over all of his competition for over 30 years.
No matter who was the greatest, Efren advanced the games farther than anyone else imo, he was making kick shots in the hole or to a dead safety , when most champions were just trying to hit the ball, of course they had to get better and did. He mastered the tit shots before anyone else , the rail first banks in one pocket. Nobody was shooting those back in the 70s, before him they were just trick shots when you got bored, he made them viable weapons. Any pool room you go in and watch good players at one pocket, you keep seeing Efrens shots and moves over and over, No one knew where to leave him , because he always had a return shot that made you sick that you chose that spot to leave him in.
I do think his break especially at 9 ball was a big deficit, but he still beat all of the other champions despite it, that is hard to believe actually , because when you ask any great player what is the most important part of the game , it's always the break.
If he had the break of Wade Crane , Tony Ellin or Shannon Daulton, well, who knows.
And please everyone, I am a huge fan of Jose Parica, don't make it something it is not. I just reread this and realized we both slept "The Lion". He was one of the few guys that pushed Efren, an amazing player and worthy of any conversation about the "Greats"
I have one Parica story I think most will like. I watched him spotting a very well known player, I can't remember the spot exactly , but it was serious, like the last 3 or something like that in a race to 7, They were both playing one handed but Jose had to play jacked up.
Jose just ran out every game like he was using 2 hands , I would have bet every dime I could get my hands on , no one could play that well jacked up, especially someone his height . Maybe 5'4" ?