SJM at the 2023 Derby City Catastrophe

decent dennis

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I believe they are contractually obligated to clear out all those tables Sunday — and of course there is the not so small matter of plane tickets for many of the players and spectators.

Don’t limit the fields and don’t increase the number of available tables and it will be Groundhog Day, again.

And no, clearly, from Stu’s post it was not the way it has been nor the way it should be. Having been to 20+ Derby's I can vouch for this.

So exactly how many iterations of this event are the players and spectators suppose to allow for them to get their act together on issues such as Wi-Fi and scheduling? They’ve been at the current venue, with its attendant issues, for over 10 years.

As to the food, OK, sure. Some guys are fine with eating beef jerky and granola bars in their room. I suppose you can go the extra step and bring in the hot plate and rice cooker. But, it is a hotel/casino and I feel it’s a reasonable expectation, when the venue is miles from other options, they provide decent vitels. I’ve been lucky enough to have traveled plenty in my life and I’d venture to say that the cheapest hotel/casino in Reno offers better food options than what’s been available to us at this venue since they built out the casino and did away with the sports bar, buffet, Asian sit down, and ice cream shop, dude.

Lou Figueroa
Have you tried my wife’s jerky?
 

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
Lots of good replies in this thread. Dishing out the blame for a poorly managed event is not and never will be my aim here. The intent is to identify the problems and let the producers know that the interests of fans in attendance, fans watching on stream, and those who competed were compromised by these problems, in the hope that these problems are addressed.

Here's a thought. Many who've gone to the Derby for many years know that the nine ball was race to seven for many years. The dead money was just as dead back then and the same guys won when they switched to race to nine. In fact, SVB has won four DCC 9ball titles, two in the race-to-seven era and two in the race-to-nine era.

It's a safe bet that the switch to nine was to accommodate the pros, but we are still paying the price. If going back to race to seven is overdoing it, why not just go back to race to seven until Round 10, and then race to nine. I think that such a format would make a 500+ player field practical and would still allow the elite to battle it out for the title with the longer race.

Though it was an awful mess this year, the Derby City Classic remains a winning idea.
 
Last edited:

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
One thing I should have shared was the audacity of the tournament directors in the Billy Thorpe vs Anthony Meglino match in One Pocket Round 8. It was the last match of the round and it was backing up the entire tournament.

Here's what happened. Meglino's play was outstanding as he jumped out to a well-deserved 2-0 lead. Thorpe had to grind out two very lengthy racks to reach double hill and the marathon match would have to continue.

It was at this point that the inconceivable happened. The tournament directors came to their table and requested that they play one-ball one pocket, meaning a rack with just one ball on the table to decide the match. Former one pocket champion Thorpe, quite reasonably, absolutely refused and was quite vocal in taking exception. In the end, the request was withdrawn and Thorpe and Meglino played out the match as intended, with Thorpe prevailing in the very well-played but interminable match.

I simply couldn't believe that the tournament directors had the audacity to make this request. Why should the players pay this price for the ineptitude of those managing the schedule. Even I was mad!
 

sjm

Older and Wiser
Silver Member
Let's share a positive about this Derby. The tactical play was often breathtaking. Several top pros with whom I spoke agreed that the disallowance of jump cues makes the game more beautiful tactically. Anyone who thinks they're needed should take note that (with apologies to Ko Pin Yi, Albin Ouschan and Jayson Shaw) the best user of the jump stick in the world, Fedor Gorst, won the nine-ball without it.
 

u12armresl

One Pocket back cutter
Silver Member
The Showboat in AC is no longer a casino, should be more than enough room tables considering all the gambling machines/tables are gone. Only a few places(maybe 2) for food, but it's connected to the Hard Rock next door, maybe a minute or 2 walk indoors
You completely change the dynamic and the type of player who would show up by moving it that far away.
 

iusedtoberich

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Ice cream shop gone too🥲🥲
I think my favorite memory was right before closing time of the ice cream shop (I think 2am?), I was in the action room, and everyone was betting high. Then all of a sudden, final ice cream runs were made, and half the room had huge shit eating grins on their faces, eating ice cream, and looked like 6 year old boys. It was such a great moment.
 

kkdanamatt

AzB Gold Member
Gold Member
Silver Member
The bigfoot is a complete waste of time. Over 2000 matches were played, the stream subscriber got to watch 35-40 of them. I really wanted to see some of the banks, wanted to see some players like Raga. Got to see mostly 10 ball on the bigfoot, which is not even a part of the actual tournament. The finals were a joke. This is not the first time it boiled down to two completely exhausted players, I believe it happened at either the US Open or International Open as well - Filler was so exhausted he played like an APA 6 speed. It is extremely disappointing as a fan to see players work so hard to a finals with players who have been playing 20 hours plus. That kind of pool is for meth heads and adderall junkies, I have no interest in watching it. At some point it has to become unacceptable to exploit professional pool players, and their fans, in this way.
This never happened at the International.
 

iusedtoberich

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Lots of good replies in this thread. Dishing out the blame for a poorly managed event is not and never will be my aim here. The intent is to identify the problems and let the producers know that the interest of fans in attendance, fans watching on stream, and those who competed were compromised by these problems in the hope that these problems are addressed.

Here's a thought. Many who've gone to the Derby for many years know that the nine ball was race to seven for many years. The dead money was just as dead back then and the same guys won when they switched to race to nine. In fact, SVB has won four DCC 9ball titles, two in the race-to-seven era and two in the race-to-nine era.

It's a safe bet that the switch to nine was to accommodate the pros, but we are still paying the price. If going back to race to seven is overdoing it, why not just go back to race to seven until Round 10, and then race to nine. I think that such a format would make a 500+ player field practical and would still allow the elite to battle it out for the title with the longer race.

Though it was an awful mess this year, the Derby City Classic remains a winning idea.

The race to 9 was to get WPA sanctioning as a Tier 3? event. That was the WPA requirement at the time. Funny, I think some WPA events after that might have been races to 7, but I'm not certain of this point. That is when some of the European pros started coming (that didn't already live in the USA). I'm with you, race to 7 is perfect, and has ZERO affect on who will win.
 

u12armresl

One Pocket back cutter
Silver Member
Obviously Caesars wouldn't let a food truck in the parking lot but you'd think there's somewhere nearby where some enterprising taco or burger truck owner could park for a few days and make $$$$$.
Wouldn't have to be on the property. If properly licensed, they can pull up on the road off of Caesars and they would have more business than they could handle.
 

iusedtoberich

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Let's share a positive about this Derby. The tactical play was often breathtaking. Several top pros with whom I spoke agreed that the disallowance of jump cues makes the game more beautiful tactically. Anyone who thinks they're needed should take note that (with apologies to Ko Pin Yi, Albin Ouschan and Jayson Shaw) the best user of the jump stick in the world, Fedor Gorst, won the nine-ball without it.
This is the gist of pool. The better players always win. It could be any rule set under the sun. Efren, Busty, Alex, Shane, Earl, Varner, etc, would have all won the same events. We see this decade after decade. I actually think the mid-tier pros complain too much to make the rules "harder" as they think it will favor them better. But they still get beat by the top tier pros. I think the rules should be tweaked where necessary to make it better for the fan experience, and the tournament venue/time/space. Not to make it where pro xyz thinks he/she has the best change to win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sjm

iusedtoberich

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Wouldn't have to be on the property. If properly licensed, they can pull up on the road off of Caesars and they would have more business than they could handle.
This would be amazing. I bet though there are strict rules in place to limit it. Or, the truck vendors have no idea. All we would have to do is find a Greek with a food truck, and he would be there and make a killing.
 

jay helfert

Shoot Pool, not people
Gold Member
Silver Member
Lots of good replies in this thread. Dishing out the blame for a poorly managed event is not and never will be my aim here. The intent is to identify the problems and let the producers know that the interest of fans in attendance, fans watching on stream, and those who competed were compromised by these problems in the hope that these problems are addressed.

Here's a thought. Many who've gone to the Derby for many years know that the nine ball was race to seven for many years. The dead money was just as dead back then and the same guys won when they switched to race to nine. In fact, SVB has won four DCC 9ball titles, two in the race-to-seven era and two in the race-to-nine era.

It's a safe bet that the switch to nine was to accommodate the pros, but we are still paying the price. If going back to race to seven is overdoing it, why not just go back to race to seven until Round 10, and then race to nine. I think that such a format would make a 500+ player field practical and would still allow the elite to battle it out for the title with the longer race.

Though it was an awful mess this year, the Derby City Classic remains a winning idea.
The switch to 9 was to get sanctioning and ranking points for the players. I don’t think the 9-Ball is as much the scheduling problem as the One Pocket is.
 

Fatboy

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Wouldn't have to be on the property. If properly licensed, they can pull up on the road off of Caesars and they would have more business than they could handle.
Won’t work, the land around the casino is all their property. Nothing within walking distance. It’s a stone trap there.

Best
Fatboy
 
Top