The best playing cues IMO I've actually hit with extensively or owned and time period in which the cue was made are below(This is in the order of my preference, a little commentary with most and I had to do 7 with some shared rankings). I would still play a tournament with any one of these makers cues confidently even though I ranked them as I did.
I currently have an LP Custom on the way and from what I've heard about Lee's cues I may be changing or adding to this list.
1.Leon Sly 2010-11
-This cue has the "Hit", balance, build quality and striking sound I was looking for for at least 15 years. It's solid with great feedback and the action on the cue ball is appropriate to my stroke.
1. Ernie Martinez early 90's
-This cue gave me the hit and balance that I was looking for in all others after. Had to keep looking after trying this cue as the owner would not part with his cue.
1. Szamboti early 80's
-don't remember if it was a Gus or Barry. It just hit really nice and after playing for a few hours with it it was clear to anyone that it had been built by a master cue maker.
2. Tim Scruggs early 90's
-Hit solid and reminded me of a Richard Black I had played with and liked a lot.
3. Richard Black late 80's
-What you would expect from Mr. Black. Great playing and tightly built.
4. Samsara early 90's
-Had a wood to wood with Buck horn joint and buck horn ferrules. Really nice and lively feeling combination. Wish I had picked this one up.
5. Schon early 90's
-Fairly hard hitting solid players. One of the reasons why these kept their value over the years. I still have the first one I ever picked up and it hits a bit better than it even did new.