You did a very good job in describing the differences between Pool and Golf and bowling and poker but you really failed to describe WHY. Pool is seedy, so is poker and bowling. Bowling is loud? So is pool!
beg to disagree....pool is not loud except for the music played at 100,000 decibels. poker gambling has always had mixed venues. from the dark dens you hint to, to the bright las vegas lights, to the dorms rooms i played in 20 years ago, to the living room where i played with neighbors for the f*ck of it. pool. on the other hand has a bad rep that spans a century................and remains.
The fact is, there are plenty of reasons as to why things are successful on television. I think poker's rapid assent can be seen in the viewer's ability to play along at home. Honestly, if you took away the graphic describing what cards were held and their chances of winning, do you really think the majority of people would continue watching? Of course not! The poker world was smart enought to apply meaning to each hand by describing the probability of success.
for any of the reasons i listed above, poker has been successful, aside from its interesting % graphic. and btw,,,the man who has made TONS off tv poker, norm chad, said in an interview that the best games are poker horse racing and POOL. it's clear where he comes from. and it's obvious he knows where to make money and what to avoid, because i don't see him wasting his time trying to buoy pool.
Take a moment and ask yourself if the average person might find any of these things uninteresting while channel surfing. I assure you, if you asked your non-poolplaying friends, many of them would likely have a tough time deciding:
1. Golf - A hole in one
2. Baseball - A perfect game
3. Bowling - A 300 point game
4. No Limit Hold 'em Poker - A Royal Flush beating Four of a Kind
5. Pool - A 150 ball run
yeah, my gosh,,,,#5. you must surely be joking. the average person does not relate to pool AT ALL. you can't possibly put it up against any of the others!!!
You really have to tap into what is primal about the game. What is it that we find most interestinga?
you hit upon a basic that simply can't be translated to everyone else,,,,,what players find interesting about pool the average person couldn't care less. you're talking about what YOU like. a more common sense idea would be to show 8ball, not 14.1,,,becaue "stripes and solids" is what the average person plays.
The Miami Heat can win the championship but if Shaq goes 10 for 10 from the free-throw line in that game, which do you think people will speak of first?
that shaq can carry a team and koby can't