JB Cases said:
As a pool player you are saying this? This sounds like you are saying this from the perspective of an amateur economist. May I ask what your experience level is in manufacturing, retail, wholesale, material sourcing, labor, logistics, quality control and all the other variables that govern the development, production, and distribution of goods so that we can be on the same page when we discuss this. Because your characterization above that the "ONLY" reason a company produces goods in one place over another is not correct.
O dear o dear, I was waiting for this. Surprised that it took you so long time to get beck. I give you a story; I have just bought a product from China which is a great pice of kit. Lets break it down:
Manufacturing costs : I have no idea but it costs me in the range of $7-8000
Material,retail,wholesale,labor: Have no idea but it's included in my purchasing price.
Shipping,logistics and all the bells and whistles from China to Norway of a box which is 2x2x2m, 600Kg (would fit a couple of cues in this type of package):$445
How many pool cues could I buy from China for the same price, filling up the same volume of my current purchased product? I would guess many. Since the freight,logistics and all the bells and whistles cost $445, I think we pretty much could eliminate that cost to hardly nothing pr/ pool cue.
This company has ONE WEB PAGE. I have made my own web page and it costs me $2 a month, and now I'm actually exaggerating.
The point in this? I save MY money and the CHINESE earns theirs. There is no one in between which pulls $ because someone is living down there, knowing someone in the factory or whichever story may be used (and I'm not aim on you).
This product is built using high quality products, and do believe me - I have seen these in "highflying" web stores re-named or re-branded for a LOT of money.
JB Cases said:
Well I suppose you would. Does it make sense for someone to uproot their life and face an uphill battle against stereotypes, bigotry and racism, just to "earn more money"? I don't have to participate here and don't need to "defend" anything. I discuss these issues because I am actually here and experiencing these things from the other side. So what kind of experience do you have that allows you to make such blanket and simplistic statements?
Pretty much everything is made in low cost countries now a days. Cell phones, designer clothes, tools, electronics, cars and car components and you name it. Can you please explain to me why this is the case? Is it only because of the good food, nice weather, nice people, good quality accommodations ?
JB Cases said:
I believe that you don't go into detail because you can't go into detail.
OK, since you seems to believe that I'm making my statement from the thin air, I'll post some pictures of my Fury and my GB-5 later. I'm at work now.
But to summarize:
The Fury lost the shaft collars splitting the "ring work". Doing so the rings was obviously aluminum and trying to put it together again showed that the rings was not circular. I need to figure out the best way to rotate this in respect of the shaft to minimize the fact that the ring is sticking out.
The Fury has a wrap which as gone down the drain.
The Fury has painted "decorations" with a "Arizona Turquoise" look.
The metal cap around it's joint has fell off.
In general, I think there must have been some bad glue around where ever the cue have been produced.
Have I played with it? No and I have not bought it either. I got it for free
GB-5
Inlays has popped out and can be felt all over the cue. The shaft has so many spots of "dirty wood" (I don't know the english word for it) that you could speculate which type of wood is used. Then the points are uneven. This cue is parked 1200Km from me but I'll get my hands on it in a week.
Have I bought it? Yeas and I have played with it. Not the worst cue I have played with but certainly not worth the $1388 which was charged for it.
JB Cases said:
Again where are the details? Does a cue being "Italian made" mean it's good quality in the first place?
Longoni: I have not used one but I know two who own them and is not to happy with them. So I'm on thin ice hear
JB Cases said:
What is quality? Neither you or anyone else has come up with what a "good" cue is or established any kind of guide that has an easy way to distinguish quality levels. I am 100% positive that if I had some cues made in our Chinese factory with no known brands and set up a guy at Valley Forge who "claimed" to make them then there would be many people like you who would tout them as true quality and great examples of small cuemaker craftsmanship and tell everyone how they are better than import cues. It's funny how perception skews reality.
I don't know why you feel the need to single me out and to disrespect brands I am associated with. But if you are going to do this then please try to provide some reasoning behind your statements.
For me quality is something which manage to keep it's performance over time without falling to pieces, inlays popping out or wrap starts going up in smoke. To compare, my McDermott D22 which is possibly over 20 years, has still a good finnish (it has yellowed some areas), non of the inlays has popped out and the leather wrap is as nice as when I got it. The seem is still close to invisible. I cant say that about the Fury and the GB I have. I'm not sure how I can't link this to quality ?
I mean not to do you any disrespect of which ever brand you are working with! My experience is as mentioned above, which I base my conclusion on. If this is just linked to my two cues, then I apologize for trying to say that this is the case of all the cues. But I would then love to have a GB cue which is 20+ years and flawless.
JB Cases said:
And Kaz Miki, who owns Mezz, is a Fury distributer and has consulted on the construction and design of the Fury cues. Rodney Morris pulled a stock Fury cue off the wall in Valley Forge 2003 and took second to Johnny Archer in the pro event with it. Another well known professional plays with one that he bought and has won several events with it. And the list goes on.
Read my post again. I did not say ANYTHING about poor quality of MEZZ !!!! I said that a friend have one and it was GOOOD
JB Cases said:
Again, what is your qualification to judge the relative quality of cues? What is your basis for saying that an import cue is low quality? Please provide us with some specific criteria to use in the comparisons. On the economic side of the aisle demand fuels supply. Consumers demand value and they receive it with the variety of relatively inexpensive cues currently available. "Good old cues from the 80's"

You sure know how to make a guy feel old.
Read my experiences above. If I don't qualify by owning two of the cues you seem to work with, I herby pull out from this discussion and leave it to the experts. I'm 35 years old, started playing when I was 14 and used cues named Pool League and Dufferin before my first McDermott in 87. Grey hears have popped out but I do feel fresh. Still
JB Cases said:
Yes you are pretty much saying that.
Again, I think you're view has colored my post to much where you "read everything is bad". I did not say that! I like MEZZ cues, and if there are other pool cues made some where down in China with good quality (Mezz is from Japan), thats fine. But don't put Fury and GB in that basket because of the mentioned reasons. There have been other so called US Made cues made down in Asia which has been produced by Mezz for many years, and I have no idea how these was doing on the US marked. I leave that to comment to those who knows Mali and the others.
JB Cases said:
"A shameful amount of money", that is an interesting phrase. I have to ask when we started looking at everyone's books to determine what amount of profit one is allowed to make? Do you have any idea what it costs to produce a Gold Crown pool table? Or the what the marketing costs per table are? How about the logistics costs of moving a pool table around the world and getting it to your door and set up properly so that it lives up to the Brunswick name? It's funny though because there are plenty of Brunswick copies out there that you can buy for a third of the price and which are nearly as good as the real thing.
Well, this was just a example. It seems like the mentioned brand is burning the candle in both ends in my world. They are to expensive where the Dynamic tables seems to take over the marked. If it was due to the local dealer was charging to much, I have a sneaking feeling that he would have reduced the price a long time ago... Which he has not done. I wonder why if his margins are so big?
As mentioned, shipping a 2x2x2m , 600KG wooden box from China costs me $455. If I plan to fill the whole container it would cost me arround $1200 if I'm not mistaking. Even if I send just one table costing $15000 the S&H is not the big expense... I would fit a couple of tables in a large container, wouldn't I ????
JB Cases said:
You use the name Newton and yet you won't analyze the situation in the true tradition of Isaac Newton's laws of the universe or Adam Smith's economic laws.
I use the nick Newton because I HAVE A NEWTON. Now you are being personal and stepping on my feet, which I'm polite enough to let pass without firing back tons of crap. We are civilized person and should behave like it.
JB Cases said:
What I mean Newton is that in business one charges the correct price according to what the market will pay or one goes out of business.
In other words, move to a low cost country to maximize the profit.
JB Cases said:
If Gold Crowns are truly $15,000 in your country then there is either a very good reason for it or the distributer is stupid to price themselves out of the market and open the door for lower priced copies.
http://www.biljardeksperten.no/cgi-private/shop/mainfake9.html - hit the top left button "Biljardbord" and divide whichever price (the highest number) by 5.4 and you have US $.
JB Cases said:
The fact of the matter is that the reasons that prices are the way they are, that goods are produced where they are, and that quality levels vary are complex and cannot be reduced simply to "making more money".
When Nokia fires up a new factory in China, is this because they are not trying to make more money? I do agree that quality control, materials and some human factors could be complex down there, but why do they bother if there is no candy in their pockets after sorting out the hazel and problems?
I don't mind having products made in Chine if the products passes a good quality control and the outcome is a solid product. If a pool cue manufacturer is so happy with the outcome of his products, I do however wonder why those small stickers saying "Made in China" is not glued to the cue??? However having a lot of cues in the marked which is falling apart is for me not the best way of recruiting young players which has used their savings on a cue....
I have actually proven my point by buying a quality product from China which have given me good follow up and service so far. But the bonus is that I save MY money.
I leave at at that. Keep on making you're cases down there (they look great) and hopefully you make a living out of it. Spending you're income in investing in new machines is something everybody would do and is pretty obvious when you run a company. I'm doing the same, which is pretty Mickey Mouse type of economy which every one understands.
Have to actually work now.
N