I think Kent Davis of So. Cal is one of the greatest cue makers around!
Check out his work at : http://www.kentdaviscues.com/custom-pool-cues-kent-davis-master-of-burl/
I have seen and played with several of his cues, they all hit amazing! My favorite is the 61" cue he made for Tall Tony O, I will post a pic of that when I can. But here are some other examples of his craftsmanship!
Something you might look into is a Rauenzahn cue. Absolutely amazing workmanship and phenomenal hit.
But, as has been stated, everything is subjective. Talk to deanoc...
I have to agree, and My Pal Scott Lokey is letting one go, its the second one from the right!
Check out this one, it's the second from the right, very suave! And only $1275!
I think this is such a great topic because it is obvious that every pool player including myself is so passionate about their cues. bottom line is there are a ton of great cue makers out there and it is a matter of opinion and every one has their own and most of them differ. personally I play with a James White cue and I love it. Chris Nitti is one of the greatest people you will ever meet and he makes a great cue as well.