Look at the number of women players compared to # of male players, that should help answer your thread.
hard to ignore how many fewer women play(ed) pool in the first place
Exactly... I don't by into the farce that pool in any form has some element that determines women can't complete with men. It's far more obvious that it's a numbers game. ...and even in that smaller number the women have complete against not only the men to break through, but the whole ideal that women shouldn't/can't play the game as well.Yep.
Think of it like comparing one random state vs. the rest of the USA - what are the chances the best player comes from the one random state?
How does this not work? In 1980 82% of NFL players came from Canada. In 1990 it was 75%. It's been somewhat over 50% most of the 2000s. Canadian provinces have generally been a Jan 1 cutoff, right? Even if the remainder of the players came from places with Sept 1 cutoffs (i.e., US states), that still makes the US players in the Jan, Feb Mar group the second oldest group of US players. Overall the 1st Q group is going to have a lot higher average age. This is really an amazing statistic, imo.Here in Oregon a child must be 6 years old on or before sept 1 to enter first grade. Therefore a child born on sept 2 would be in the same grade as a child born on aug 31 of the following year and be an entire year older. The oldest kids are born in the fourth trimester the exact opposite of your NHL graph and it's implications. When you spot one thing jinky it makes a person start to question many of the assumptions used for the conclusions.
[...]
I have no information about how Canadian schools cut off kids for grades but you can't dig gold in a silver mine. Most of America does not play hockey so it's no surprise half the players in the NHL come from a country with less population than California. In America the first quarter kids will be on average three months younger than the fourth quarter kids. That's just simple math.How does this not work? In 1980 82% of NFL players came from Canada. In 1990 it was 75%. It's been somewhat over 50% most of the 2000s. Canadian provinces have generally been a Jan 1 cutoff, right? Even if the remainder of the players came from places with Sept 1 cutoffs (i.e., US states), that still makes the US players in the Jan, Feb Mar group the second oldest group of US players. Overall the 1st Q group is going to have a lot higher average age. This is really an amazing statistic, imo.
in pool, the differences are not physical, they are psychological (in other sports the differences are usually physical). Men are conditioned to be more competitive. They learn at an early age that their entire worth only depends on whether they can win or not. Women are generally not taught this, but they can be just as competitive as men. Take Serena Williams, she has a competitive spirit that rivals the best male players. If she chose pool over tennis, she'd be close to the top
Find this spatial thinking bias funny as I always believed women were superior to men ?A physics professor looked at this subject years ago. His conclusion was some women have problems with spatial relations ( the ability to perceive two or more object's position in space ( pool table ) relative to oneself and to each other ). To me, men and women have a problem with seeing the table layout and thinking 3 balls ahead in rotation games. How many amateur men can compete with the top women on tour ?In the 70's, I made a couple of road trips with Seattle Sam and Lori Shampo, a very good women player. She could beat a lot of male players. I believe that if more women wanted to become good players, they could be taught to play as well /or better than most amateur men.
Just my opinion.
You must mean the NHL (National Hockey League). I doubt that there are many Canadians playing football in the NFL.How does this not work? In 1980 82% of NFL players came from Canada. In 1990 it was 75%. It's been somewhat over 50% most of the 2000s. Canadian provinces have generally been a Jan 1 cutoff, right? Even if the remainder of the players came from places with Sept 1 cutoffs (i.e., US states), that still makes the US players in the Jan, Feb Mar group the second oldest group of US players. Overall the 1st Q group is going to have a lot higher average age. This is really an amazing statistic, imo.
As a Canadian, I was floored when I read NFL...lol. I think generally we have a few that break through to the NFL, but that would be the end of it.You must mean the NHL (National Hockey League). I doubt that there are many Canadians playing football in the NFL.
Completely agree... If someone wants to post a study showing men having greater aptitude for spatial whatever and want to equate that to playing pool. Then I'll take a moment and post two studies that show that there is no distinct adventage at all.My opinion remains that there is no mental or physical reason why a woman can't play pool just as good as any man.