IMO you NEVER pick up any ball if you're the ref without marking its position first. Every good ref has a ball marker in their pocket. You can also mark a ball's position by using chalk. No excuse for not doing it.Here’s the shot that Mika complained about. The ref just lifted the 9 and then set it back down when he pulled out the template. Shane barely had a shot but made the 1. At the end of the game, Mika told the ref he should have used a marker. Shane (who probably should have stayed out of it) said it didn’t change the shot, and it went back and forth a few times.
I’m curious if people agree that you need to mark a ball to pick up the template. It’s one thing to pick up the cue ball to clean it, but it’s a different thing to just lift up a single ball a little, slide the template out, and put the ball back down. I’m not sure I agree that you need to mark it first.
View attachment 636826
If you ask me why he should do that, my answer is that even when picking up a ball only a "millimeter" it's possible that your arm might be bumped or the ball may even fall or slip from your grasp. What then? Guess where it should go? Mark it and then you have no worries about where to spot it. I have seen referees drop balls more than once.
I have also watched a referee turn a ball around when a player complained about a chalk mark on the ball. The proper action would be to mark the ball, pick it up, clean it and then set it back down.
Last edited: