kyelin said:Hi..
long shot here... looking for westinghouse yellow micarta... for ferrules/joint... let me know. Thanks.
qbilder said:Mason has some newer age micarta, still yellow but linen based instead of paper. I tried some & it's nearly identical to the weight, hit, feel of original Westinghouse micarta. The only difference I see is the base pattern, but it's still yellow.
qbilder said:Mason has some newer age micarta, still yellow but linen based instead of paper. I tried some & it's nearly identical to the weight, hit, feel of original Westinghouse micarta. The only difference I see is the base pattern, but it's still yellow.
pdcue said:Not exactly.
I have no desire to be argumentative here, but I do feel
motivated to provide a few facts I've picked up. Many of which
came from conversations with the Product Manager of Micarta at Westinghouse in South Carolina.
Demystifying Micarta somewhat.
First off 'Micarta' is a trademarked brand designation only,
and NOT a material specification of any kind. That is the reason
you can still buy Micarta, though it is now many years and several
corporatins removed from Westinghouse and South Carolina.
Westinghouse called all their reinforced plastics Micarta.
Most were laminates, many were phenolic resin products, for
example, the much beloved 'natural' <rusty red> colored
linen Phenolic made so popular by Kersenbrock and
subsequently SouthWest Cues. They also made a product
that eventually morphed into G10.
Mason's material, IIUC - is a laminated phenolic rolled around a mandrel.
Much like phenolic joint collars and butt caps.
The real deal yellow Micarta was not laminated and it is NOT
a phenolic resin at all.
It is also NOT reinforced with paper 'paper'.
I know everybody called it paper, they also called it white.
I have not hit with any of the new stuff - but I have 30 years
and counting of playing with Westinghouse and I would not expect
much similarity - tho the 'feel' only matters to each individual.
FWIW - the yellow coloring and 'ageing' was what made Micarta so
popular with knife makers, and may well have been why cuemakers
decided to use it in the first place - but for the last 25 years, the
only reason I've heard from those who prefer it is the hit.
Don't get me wrong - the new material may be the best ferrule stock EVER,
but, IMHO -<not all that humble>OLD 'yellow Micarta' it ain't.
Dale Pierce<who knows waaaay too much about Micarta>
pdcue said:Not exactly.
I have no desire to be argumentative here, but I do feel
motivated to provide a few facts I've picked up. Many of which
came from conversations with the Product Manager of Micarta at Westinghouse in South Carolina.
Demystifying Micarta somewhat.
First off 'Micarta' is a trademarked brand designation only,
and NOT a material specification of any kind. That is the reason
you can still buy Micarta, though it is now many years and several
corporatins removed from Westinghouse and South Carolina.
Westinghouse called all their reinforced plastics Micarta.
Most were laminates, many were phenolic resin products, for
example, the much beloved 'natural' <rusty red> colored
linen Phenolic made so popular by Kersenbrock and
subsequently SouthWest Cues. They also made a product
that eventually morphed into G10.
Mason's material, IIUC - is a laminated phenolic rolled around a mandrel.
Much like phenolic joint collars and butt caps.
The real deal yellow Micarta was not laminated and it is NOT
a phenolic resin at all.
It is also NOT reinforced with paper 'paper'.
I know everybody called it paper, they also called it white.
I have not hit with any of the new stuff - but I have 30 years
and counting of playing with Westinghouse and I would not expect
much similarity - tho the 'feel' only matters to each individual.
FWIW - the yellow coloring and 'ageing' was what made Micarta so
popular with knife makers, and may well have been why cuemakers
decided to use it in the first place - but for the last 25 years, the
only reason I've heard from those who prefer it is the hit.
Don't get me wrong - the new material may be the best ferrule stock EVER,
but, IMHO -<not all that humble>OLD 'yellow Micarta' it ain't.
Dale Pierce<who knows waaaay too much about Micarta>
pdcue said:Not exactly.
I have no desire to be argumentative here, but I do feel
motivated to provide a few facts I've picked up. Many of which
came from conversations with the Product Manager of Micarta at Westinghouse in South Carolina.
Demystifying Micarta somewhat.
First off 'Micarta' is a trademarked brand designation only,
and NOT a material specification of any kind. That is the reason
you can still buy Micarta, though it is now many years and several
corporatins removed from Westinghouse and South Carolina.
Westinghouse called all their reinforced plastics Micarta.
Most were laminates, many were phenolic resin products, for
example, the much beloved 'natural' <rusty red> colored
linen Phenolic made so popular by Kersenbrock and
subsequently SouthWest Cues. They also made a product
that eventually morphed into G10.
Mason's material, IIUC - is a laminated phenolic rolled around a mandrel.
Much like phenolic joint collars and butt caps.
The real deal yellow Micarta was not laminated and it is NOT
a phenolic resin at all.
It is also NOT reinforced with paper 'paper'.
I know everybody called it paper, they also called it white.
I have not hit with any of the new stuff - but I have 30 years
and counting of playing with Westinghouse and I would not expect
much similarity - tho the 'feel' only matters to each individual.
FWIW - the yellow coloring and 'ageing' was what made Micarta so
popular with knife makers, and may well have been why cuemakers
decided to use it in the first place - but for the last 25 years, the
only reason I've heard from those who prefer it is the hit.
Don't get me wrong - the new material may be the best ferrule stock EVER,
but, IMHO -<not all that humble>OLD 'yellow Micarta' it ain't.
Dale Pierce<who knows waaaay too much about Micarta>
qbilder said:I remember the arguements between you & mason. I also remember it not going to any conclusive end. Nobody has ever said it's the real deal original micarta. It's a FAIR priced substitute for a material that can not be found easily anymore, and provides virtually identical playability & feel. Call it apples, call it oranges, call it disney, it doesn't matter. It is what it is, and that is an outstanding, affordable substitute for the old stuff. Though I do not have 30 years experience with any of it, I do have some experience with all of it on my own personal cues. It's the same if playability is the concern.
masonh said:they used lots of it on ships,for electrical shrouding,also bases for big tanks(like compressed gas)
masonh said:Dale with all due respect i am not so sure you know exactly what i have.it is not a exactly a phenolic resin as you staed above.i originally thought it was myself,but it isn't.it is linen based but it isn't a laminated phenolic as you say.i understand you have a vast knowledge of "old yellow" micarta and more than likely know more than i about it,but you are mistaken on which product i have.
it is hard to find statistical information on the old stuff,but i would like to bet even money that my stuff is stronger.i do know that it is quite a bit stronger than LBM and phenolic.i have shafts with the old stuff and with the new stuff and imo the new stuff has a similar feel but plays better,for my game.
masonh said:Dale i think Eric was thinking of a guy on here named Socks,who went on a micarta tirade.he was insinuating i was lying and pirating and everything else bad a man can do.he accused me of trying to pass it off as the old stuff,when i clearly stated in every thread that it is not the old suff.he went a little haywire and i am pretty sure Eric is thinking of him.