Commentating is a skill, and it’s no easy feat. I’ve stepped behind the mic myself on a non-pool-related video, and it was challenging. Most speakers today have what we in my industry call "verbal tics": “you know,” “like,” “uh,” “well,” “so,” “um,” “in fact,” and so on. Once you’re aware of them, you hear them everywhere.
If I had to choose a young person in today’s pool world to try their hand at commentating, in no particular order, I’d love to hear Joshua Filler, Savannah Easton, Mike Molina, and Fedor Gorst. Each of them brings a different energy and perspective, and it would be interesting to see how they translate that into the booth.
As for my personal favorites, it’s hard to pick just one. I tend to lean toward a blast from the past: Allen Hopkins for his knowledge, history, and strategic insight; Karl Boyes for his Sid Waddell-like voice, pitch, and infectious enthusiasm; and then a few oldies but goldies who aren’t heard as much on today’s streams like Jerry Forsyth, Billy Incardona, and Alex Lely. And as an aside, I’d love to hear commentary someday from Niels Feijen, Darren Appleton, and Johan Ruijsink. These guys know pool inside and out as well as today's pro players.
Honorable mention goes to Andrew "Drew" C-l-e-a-r-y. To me, he’s still a young’n. His quick wit, sharp knowledge of the game and today’s players, and hilarious commentary would make him an absolute blast to watch. He’s talented in more ways than one.
I’m not sure any young person today has quite the seasoning needed to deliver truly professional-sounding commentary, but it would certainly be fun to find out.
