Someone must agree with me a little bit because they keep experimenting with rules. Racking the nine on the spot, break boxes, rotating the break, smaller pockets, and so on.
The powers that be recognized the game could be improved. One crazy thing they could do is create a neutral ball so that they can be racked as 10 ball. Then remove the neutral ball after the break, Or just play 10 ball.
I must say I do prefer winner breaks but no Hill games, you must win by two.
I don’t know who is to be credited to as being the one who initially said it, but I’ve heard many say it over the years, “pool is the cruelest of games”. It truly is, because in its purest form, you’re not guaranteed a turn at the table, and if you don’t take advantage of the opportunities you do get, you’re not guaranteed another opportunity.
The break is key not only in 9 ball, but in all disciplines of pocket billiards, 10 ball, 1 pocket, banks, 14:1, Snooker. Why, because it’s all about controlling the table.
This isn't golf or other sports where “everyone gets a turn”. The funny thing is, all those here that are enthusiasts of the this beautiful game all learn this very early on when they take up the game. To me, it’s one of its most beautiful aspects.
You mention there must be others that agree with you and reference the constant “tinkering with the rules”. That’s something that’s only really occurred in the last 20 years or so, and you say “the powers that be recognized that the game can be improved”. That’s subjective as I and many I speak with don’t consider these rule changes improvements, it’s more like appeasing whiners that have forgotten what I mentioned above that you learn early on in this game, you’re not guaranteed a turn, and need to take full advantage of the opportunities you get. The game shouldn’t be changed because some people, through hard work and dedication rise to a skill level that others don’t aspire to, or can’t achieve. Those of tender sensibilities should play 3 cushion or other forms where you’re guaranteed a turn, or pick a new sport where everyone gets a turn to play like golf or bowling.
