Stopped ball

Interesting question and it got me thinking...Let's say a ball is hanging in a pocket (longer than 5 seconds). A follow up shot is played at the opposite end of the table and the hanging ball suddenly falls on it's own without any influence from the shot played. However, it happened to fall while balls were still live and rolling on the table. Does it count or does it get spotted back up?

Stopped ball

The official rules do specify a time limit. Here's the applicable part of the rule:

If a ball stops near the edge of a pocket, and remains apparently motionless for five seconds after the shot is over, it is not considered pocketed if it later falls into the pocket by itself (see 1.7 Balls Settling for other details). During that five second period, play is suspended.​
So, assuming the agreed rules of play were WPA, and not trad. BCA, you would have to remember to start counting to 5 immediately after the ball stopped at the edge (preferably out loud).
BTW: Inflicting a traditionally severe ‘unsportsmanlike’ penalty in an unrefereed game could be a bit much. I think I would rather rush my shot (like we used to) than argue over an exact time, and if his ball dropped after he bumped the table (regardless of time), loss of turn & restoration would have to do.

The Pause

The only time I ask a student to have a true pause at the end of the back stroke is if they punch the ball with a very, very short back stroke. Often they have nice long, smooth warmup strokes, and then JAB! The pause forces them to have a controlled backstroke.

I never really learned a pause. I can demonstrate it, but I can't play with one.

I do think a pause is needed at address, with the tip close to the ball.

When I took a lesson with Scott Lee many years ago, he told me that his review of pro players showed that there was always a pause on the backstroke, even if it was momentary or extremely short.

I see a lot of amateur players that have a jerky transition between the backstroke and the stroke itself, especially on shots where they have to hit the ball hard, and I think the pause is very helpful to counteract that. Do you not see players with that jerky transition? If so, what do you recommend?

Dynasphere Rhodium balls $220 shipped.

Brands new set of Dynasphere Rhodium balls that have never even been taken out of the box and still in cellophane. $220 shipped PayPal. No lower price on eBay or anywhere else. Seyberts is $260 plus tax. U can do F&F or as a transaction. I ship within 24 hours. Check my feedback everybody got exactly what I described.

Attachments

  • IMG_0340.jpeg
    IMG_0340.jpeg
    306 KB · Views: 61

My Little Joss Group

Nah, I didn't even drop my pants.

Besides, if I wanted to show off I would pop open my Danbuilt case, or my 12x12 O'Neil...or the big barrel case... 🤪 :ROFLMAO:

I have two other ATA cases, just no pics of them that I can find.

View attachment 940283

View attachment 940284

View attachment 940285


Or just show the original humble home of the Joss...

View attachment 940286

View attachment 940287

I could show the 6x6 O'Neil, but the original sticker is peeling on one corner, so it's probably junk now... :unsure:
Tease...

Qatar World Cup 10-Ball 2026

It's amazing how Filler hasn't won a US Open since 2019, or a World Championship in 9 Ball since 2018.

He needs to put that right next year.

Winning the Qatar Open does nothing for his legacy, it's a crap event with zero history and zero audience.
Yes, but he has won two China Opens since then (three in total). Not sure how long you have been around pool, but until fairly recently, the China Open may well have been tougher to win than the US Open. He also won the 2022 World Games gold medal, a World Teams Championship gold medal since then, and a World 8ball gold medal since then. The "what have you done for me lately?" argument hardly applies here. Filler is the greatest and most consistent mass-producer of major titles of the current generation of pool players and nobody else is even close.

All that said, I'm sure he wants the most prestigious titles the most, just as you suggest. With a silver and a bronze already, I know how badly he wants a World 10ball title, because he has told me.

Kind of agree with you, though, about the Qatar World Cup. It doesn't have the history of some of the other top events, I also agree that it can be hard to take events having almost no audience seriously, but then you must downgrade the recent Jeddah World 9ball events from consideration, too. A high first prize does not, alone, make a tournament great. Still, the Qatar World Cup is an elite event, about five years old, that always draws a killer field, just as it did this year, and its profile as an event continues to rise. I feel that every major championship adds to a player's legacy but agree that Qatar should not qualify as one of Filler's career highlights.

Since the game went globally viral about a decade ago, we live in a world where the majors have very deep fields (often 256) with dozens capable of winning. That's why nobody other than Josh has won more than one major singles title this year, while Josh has four. For me, a major means an event having an internationally diverse field of at least 96 players with a first prize of at least $25,000. I think it's unrealistic to expect Josh to fill in the gaps of which you take note next year. Also, are these gaps really noteworthy given that he has already won the titles noted and pretty much all of the most prestigious titles?

Filler's great, a living legend, but maybe not quite as great as you seem to believe. He'll continue to be a contender at every major in every discipline, but in this era of the game, in which fields are much deeper than they were even ten years, ago, everybody is beatable and my guess is that nobody will produce a year like Varner '89 or Immonen '09 for a very long time.

Overall, I think you made good points, because some of the majors are more important as legacy-builders than others, and we should not lose sight of this.

However it all pans out, though, it will be fun to watch.

Kiely comes from the loss side to win Iron Table Tour stop at Branford Cue & Brew in CT

Connecticut has always been something of an under-achieving competitor in the world of major US pool tours. It has and continues to host, twice a year at Yale Billiards in Wallingford, CT, one of the country’s longest, continuously-operating professional tours, the New York-based Joss NE Open 9-Ball Tour. And since Jayson Shaw opened his room, US 1 Billiards in West Haven, the state has played host to a number of major events, featuring some of the more prominent names in the game. Lodged between New York and the rest of New England, Connecticut seems to have settled in to become more […]

See full article...

Filter

Back
Top