Unsportsmanlike Conduct Rule
For many years, 14.1 players I encountered took intentional fouls by merely touching the CB with the tip without moving it. The official rules however, require that the shot be ‘stroked’. I assume, if YOUR opponent committed that ‘un-stroked’ foul in a non-refereed match, you would probably just warn him, and have him repeat the shot (?).At least he is probably on two at that point.
But, in an official refereed/pro tournament, where it’s assumed that players should know better, that might qualify as a ‘serious’ foul, and a mere warning wouldn’t be sufficient. It’s always been common knowledge that intentionally striking the CB with your ferrule wasn’t allowed, and a 15 point penalty & re-break might thus be correct. I wonder though, if a lesser penalty might be justified for any traditional misunderstanding of the rules? A more graduated scale between ‘one point with warning’ and ‘15 points with re-break’.