sjm said:Well, I'll have to defer to you on this one, Jay, as I attended just a few women's nine ball events in the 1980's, but I recall that the cloth at the 1988 Women's US Open played pretty fast.
Still, I'm far more interested in your view on whehter Allison or Jean is the one favored by the slower conditions. I believe that Allison's ball pocketing edge is a huge advantage on slow cloth, as there are so many more hard hits of the cue ball, which makes the pockets play a little tighter. Jean's bigger stroke is an advantage, but the shots in which Jean would have a significant edge over Allison (who has a bigger stroke than many realize) would be few and far between.
I think that slow cloth would increase, not decrease, the advantage already enjoyed by the ball-pocketing machines that women's snooker has brought to the WPBA, because they pocket so ccurately even at high speed.
What's your view? Others encouraged to chime in, too.
Allison would be a winner under any conditions. She is mentally strong! If she had been over here 20 years ago, she would have given Jean fits. And maybe a reason to keep playing.