Hotel Kick-backs to Tournament Promoters

The Saw

Juicy Pop in 2016!
Silver Member
Here's a typical example of what happens. You are an event planner. Hotel rooms in a market are going for, say $200 during a certain season. You negotiate for a $129 rate with a $15 per night rebate (built in to the $129) a year or two before the event. You block and guarantee usage of 200 of the hotels 800 rooms.

If all goes well, the regular price goes out at $200 and the hotel is doing well, then climbs to $249 then $299. You now look like a genius because your people are paying $129 and your block quickly sells out.

If it does not go well, the regular price goes out at $200 and the hotel is doing poorly, drops their rate to $149 on Expedia Priceline 60 days before your event, then still doing poorly, drops to $99 because they are only 60% full. Your block lingers and your participants flock to the lower rates. You are in trouble. You complain to the hotel but your little block is not helping them very much - they need to compete with X hotel next door who is selling their rooms at $79 because of a bed bug infestation and a remodeling job.

You now look like a greedy idiot, yet both of these situations are completely out of your control.

What Fran needs to understand is that hotel rates are not static: they are market driven, just like stocks. The value is simply relative to the market.





Two months before the hotel the hotel revenue manager

Okay, okay buddy, move along..... Ain't no one got no time for you coming in here with all of your common sense making sense having actual factual real world knowledge or actual factual things. Please cease and desist or we will call the thought police and turn you and your actual factual information in to the improper authorities. Fran Crimi may even threaten to sue you for making sense.
 

TATE

AzB Gold Mensch
Silver Member
Okay, okay buddy, move along..... Ain't no one got no time for you coming in here with all of your common sense making sense having actual factual real world knowledge or actual factual things. Please cease and desist or we will call the thought police and turn you and your actual factual information in to the improper authorities. Fran Crimi may even threaten to sue you for making sense.

Thanks Saw. I do have experience. I've been negotiating hotel contracts for professional events for over 30 years and it's what I do for a living. Rebates are simply a fact of life in the events business and they became more prevalent and widely offered by hotels during the recession (although I've negotiated for them for my entire career).

Realistically, in most cases an event promoter can only hope to get room bookings for a portion of the group. I would say 40% - 70% depending on location and value is pretty typical. The smart ones work with these numbers in mind. Many attendees have rewards programs at other hotels, time share, points redemption and barter arrangements.
 

SJDinPHX

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Maybe if you left the Booze, and Smokes alone you would understand.

CooCoo, If I was not totally 'blind, falling down drunk', what do you think the odds would be of me EVER responding to
one of your posts ? :sorry:

And my smoking is kinda like your spelling, and John Barton's 'stroke'..It ain't easy to quit our stupidest habits, is it ! :killingme:

View attachment irony%2016.jpg
 
Last edited:

8ballEinstein

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Okay, okay buddy, move along..... Ain't no one got no time for you coming in here with all of your common sense making sense having actual factual real world knowledge or actual factual things. Please cease and desist or we will call the thought police and turn you and your actual factual information in to the improper authorities. Fran Crimi may even threaten to sue you for making sense.

Mark Griffin and TATE - plenty of credibility
Fran Crimi - been slipping a bit lately ...
 

dardusm

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
We have serious difference of opinion if you think 300 a hour is reasonable?

Nurses, doctors and lawyers don't make 300 a hour!

First pays 1k director gets 3k hours directly worked is 6 day one and 4 day two.

Its utter bs!

Kd

Even with tournaments, it's still supply and demand. If the tournament isn't good (payouts, tables, etc.) then don't play. The only way a tournament director makes this kind of money is that the players are supporting the event.
 

CocoboloCowboy

Cowboys are my hero's
Silver Member
Next thing you guys will be complaining about is the price of a bottle of water at an NFL Game where the fan get change $4.00-$6.00 for a bottle that cost $3.99/Case of 24.

If you don't like the price of water, or the kickbacks, don't go to the game, or tournament. SIMPLE SOLUTION.
 

lfigueroa

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Thanks Saw. I do have experience. I've been negotiating hotel contracts for professional events for over 30 years and it's what I do for a living. Rebates are simply a fact of life in the events business and they became more prevalent and widely offered by hotels during the recession (although I've negotiated for them for my entire career).

Realistically, in most cases an event promoter can only hope to get room bookings for a portion of the group. I would say 40% - 70% depending on location and value is pretty typical. The smart ones work with these numbers in mind. Many attendees have rewards programs at other hotels, time share, points redemption and barter arrangements.


Tate, I'm curious: have you negotiated contracts with casinos, specifically Caesars Entertainment?

Lou Figueroa
 

cardiac kid

Super Senior Member
Silver Member
Next thing you guys will be complaining about is the price of a bottle of water at an NFL Game where the fan get change $4.00-$6.00 for a bottle that cost $3.99/Case of 24.

If you don't like the price of water, or the kickbacks, don't go to the game, or tournament. SIMPLE SOLUTION.

You're correct CoCo. That is a simple solution. Unfortunately we all live in the real world. Whether we buy a car, water or an entry into an event, someone is making money off of us. I'm not happy about it but, what is your solution? Sit home and veg? How about starting an event and doing it the way we want? Who do think will be standing at the end of the experiment? Come on, we both know the answer.

My problem is more with people who keep telling me what a great deal they're giving me while reaching in my back pocket for more and more money. The guises are different but in the end, the result is the same. I'd prefer honesty. Not much around anymore.

Lyn
 

Kid Dynomite

Dennis (Michael) Wilson
Silver Member
Even with tournaments, it's still supply and demand. If the tournament isn't good (payouts, tables, etc.) then don't play. The only way a tournament director makes this kind of money is that the players are supporting the event.
No, people are ignorant of what is going on. How many people read the fine print?

That is why public discussion enlightens many people. That is why people are brave enough to touch on sensitive and taboo topics.

The original poster was hoping to hear or read a comment debunking the topic. As such, the public debate began!

Each reader is free to form their own opinion. Do some research and investigate for yourself! Hell, there are only 5 or 6 events/promoters it should not be too hard. "You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink" don't expect others to do all the heavy lifting and provide it on a Silver plater!

The regional tour shenanigans has been discussed on here before. So, look it up if you care to.

Kd
 

cardiac kid

Super Senior Member
Silver Member
"You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink" don't expect others to do all the heavy lifting and provide it on a Silver plater! kd

KD,

You can also "lead a horse to water and sometimes it drowns". Once a promoter gets the feeling they can continue to raise prices without returning value to the players, it becomes the active mentality. Only when players stop attending the event do they begin to recognize the problem and react. All the negative posts on AZ will do nothing. A few hundred (or more) mssing players will do lots.

Lyn
 

Kid Dynomite

Dennis (Michael) Wilson
Silver Member
KD,

You can also "lead a horse to water and sometimes it drowns". Once a promoter gets the feeling they can continue to raise prices without returning value to the players, it becomes the active mentality. Only when players stop attending the event do they begin to recognize the problem and react. All the negative posts on AZ will do nothing. A few hundred (or more) mssing players will do lots.

Lyn
Yes, but how does the promoter know it was in response to that issue? They are not mind readers and may believe it due to inclement weather, 911 or some other non related event. The players are so unorganized and promoters like it that way!

Kd
 

cardiac kid

Super Senior Member
Silver Member
Yes, but how does the promoter know it was in response to that issue? They are not mind readers and may believe it due to inclement weather, 911 or some other non related event. The players are so unorganized and promoters like it that way!

Kd

Excellent point. BCAPL faced that question when they moved from the Riv to Rio. Did the attendence drop because of the new month? The new venue? The airline / fuel price rise? Too high venue prices? Hate to admit it but your unorganized comment is spot on.

ACS actually gained entries after moving from the Riv to Tropicana. Don't know what to attribute that to.

Lyn
 

Bambu

Dave Manasseri
Silver Member
I've never seen so many good people get so snotty over a post. It's simply uncalled for, blowback or not.
 

jay helfert

Shoot Pool, not people
Gold Member
Silver Member
Good responses by Mark G. and Tate, spoken from experience, Unless one has actually been a promoter and worked with the Sales department of hotels they don't know what goes into these negotiations.

I've probably produced several dozen pool tournaments in hotels and casinos over the last 25 years and every deal looked different. Typically a hotel will give you the ballroom for free if you meet certain room block requirements. Casinos are not as strict about giving up ballroom space. If you can bring bodies to their facility (whether they stay there or not) they are happy, because they know they will make money from everyone who attends. The hotels need to make money from the room sales, they don't have a casino to generate income.

As for myself one of the first things I negotiate with a hotel is the room rates. I know that if I don't get an attractive rate for my players they will stay somewhere else, and I won't make my room guarantee. As an example, when I did my last event at the Burbank Hilton Hotel, the regular room rate at that time was $129. I negotiated a $99 a night rate for my attendees. I got ZERO kickback of any kind! What I did get was a $5,000 a day ballroom for free if we booked enough rooms. If the bookings fell short, I would have to make up the balance at the going rate of $99 a night for however many nights it took. The hotel put a hold on my credit card for $10,000! And that my friends is the name of that tune.

Casino hotels are entirely different as I said before. At the Sands in Reno, I got the ballroom free as part of the deal, no guarantee required. With them I negotiated a room rate of $29/nite for a single and $39 for a double room. This was in line with the best prices they offer online during a slow season. I needed to book a total of 800 room nights to get a kickback. If it fell short I got nothing, but if it went over I got $5 per room night. That was a big bonus for me if I could bring enough people that would stay at the Sands. 800 room nights meant a $4,000 bonus! In the first few years I never quite made it, sometimes falling short by less than fifty room nights. Maybe in the fifth or sixth year I finally got over 800 room nights, so my event became a lot more lucrative for me as the promoter.

The above is an example of a good deal for the players and the promoter alike, and is somewhat typical of what usually happens at casino/hotels. I will go one step further in answering the OP's original question. At it's peak my net income for producing the U.S. Bar Table Championships was never much more than $10-15,000, with maybe the last two years close to the higher number. That, after six months of planning, probably the last three months working on it daily, and then a final tournament week of 12-14 hour days. I'm sure I could have made more money managing a MacDonalds.

It isn't easy to turn a profit running a pool tournament and my hat is off to the promoters who can do it. It took me years to figure out how to accomplish this and along the way I lost as much as 20K in one event! Nice job huh? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

336Robin

Multiverse Operative
Silver Member
Kickbacks?

A frequent practice in organizing a big event is for the promoter to receive a kick-back from the hotels where the players are staying. The hotel may increase its rates to compensate for the kick-back.

That means that the players are paying more than just their entry fee. They're also unknowingly contributing to the tournament 'added money' out of their own pockets.

When you have a group of people staying at a hotel for an event, the rates should be discounted, not inflated.

If you're thinking of attending an event, try to find out what the hotel normally would charge for that time of year if there hadn't been an event. Then compare it with the rate you have to pay. Is it discounted? It should be. Is it inflated? It shouldn't be.

Ive tried to make financial sense out of promoting and this has never been a problem. Likely the only perk you get is a comped room and that is only if you bring in a certain number of rooms to the hotel. If you are using a certain room or rooms for the event you get charged a gargantuan amount of money per day for them. If you get a certain number of patrons or business you might get some of that discounted.

There is no way that you can charge that money into the entry fees for the event. THe fee you charge the players is what it is and comes out of entries and is upfront and known.

Promoting an event is a thankless task and someone has to pay for its being in existence which is why there are so many events. Its a great way to lose money because no one helps you with anything. I like the idea of sponsorship but little of that is going on either.

Promoters have to make money, if players want to play then they either enter the events they have or they simply match up if they don't like the events.
 

TATE

AzB Gold Mensch
Silver Member
Tate, I'm curious: have you negotiated contracts with casinos, specifically Caesars Entertainment?

Lou Figueroa

Not in the modern version of Caesar's Entertainment. I did casino hotels earlier in my career and I had one group at Caesar's in Las Vegas, but this was not my specialty. Earlier in my career I did groups in Las Vegas, but I avoid them now if possible. I concentrate on high end resort meetings with the vast majority in Hawaii.

Las Vegas is definitely a seller. I don't know if it's the largest convention city in the world in terms of usable meeting space and rooms, but from my experience it's right up there.
 
Last edited:

Kid Dynomite

Dennis (Michael) Wilson
Silver Member
Good responses by Mark G. and Tate, spoken from experience, Unless one has actually been a promoter and worked with the Sales department of hotels they don't know what goes into these negotiations.

I've probably produced several dozen pool tournaments in hotels and casinos over the last 25 years and every deal looked different. Typically a hotel will give you the ballroom for free if you meet certain room block requirements. Casinos are not as strict about giving up ballroom space. If you can bring bodies to their facility (whether they stay there or not) they are happy, because they know they will make money from everyone who attends. The hotels need to make money from the room sales, they don't have a casino to generate income.

As for myself one of the first things I negotiate with a hotel is the room rates. I know that if I don't get an attractive rate for my players they will stay somewhere else, and I won't make my room guarantee. As an example, when I did my last event at the Burbank Hilton Hotel, the regular room rate at that time was $129. I negotiated a $99 a night rate for my attendees. I got ZERO kickback of any kind! What I did get was a $5,000 a day ballroom for free if we booked enough rooms. If the bookings fell short, I would have to make up the balance at the going rate of $99 a night for however many nights it took. The hotel put a hold on my credit card for $10,000! And that my friends is the name of that tune.

Casino hotels are entirely different as I said before. At the Sands in Reno, I got the ballroom free as part of the deal, no guarantee required. With them I negotiated a room rate of $29/nite for a single and $39 for a double room. This was in line with the best prices they offer online during a slow season. I needed to book a total of 800 room nights to get a kickback. If it fell short I got nothing, but if it went over I got $5 per room night. That was a big bonus for me if I could bring enough people that would stay at the Sands. 800 room nights meant a $4,000 bonus! In the first few years I never quite made it, sometimes falling short by less than fifty room nights. Maybe in the fifth or sixth year I finally got over 800 room nights, so my event became a lot more lucrative for me as the promoter.

The above is an example of a good deal for the players and the promoter alike, and is somewhat typical of what usually happens at casino/hotels. I will go one step further in answering the OP's original question. At it's peak my net income for producing the U.S. Bar Table Championships was never much more than $10-15,000, with maybe the last two years close to the higher number. That, after six months of planning, probably the last three months working on it daily, and then a final tournament week of 12-14 hour days. I'm sure I could have made more money managing a MacDonalds.

It isn't easy to turn a profit running a pool tournament and my hat is off to the promoters who can do it. It took me years to figure out how to accomplish this and along the way I lost as much as 20K in one event! Nice job huh? :rolleyes:

I commend anyone doing anything for the sport! Anyone! It hurts when they get something going and turn their backs on the players/sport. You of all people, know what I mean. Some turn their back due to gambling addiction, Some due to drug addiction, some due to greed I guess because I don't know how else to explain it???

lets face it people lose their way sometimes, pool is no different!


I still spend my money every chance I get via attending and via streaming and video sales regardless of what is going on behind the scenes. I probably will continue to support despite the bad taste it leaves in my mouth. They say "Ignorance is Bliss"" !!!

KD
 

alstl

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I doubt it is as simple as Fran suggests. I live in Columbia Missouri and there are plenty of hotels here but no pool tournaments. If promoters were raking in truckloads of cash there would be big tournaments every weekend all over the country.
 

spartan

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
What Fran needs to understand is that hotel rates are not static: they are market driven, just like stocks. The value is simply relative to the market.
Much like airline seats. Often when you check fares with the person seating next to you on a flight , you find he is paying a fraction of what you paid


As for myself one of the first things I negotiate with a hotel is the room rates. I know that if I don't get an attractive rate for my players they will stay somewhere else, and I won't make my room guarantee. As an example, when I did my last event at the Burbank Hilton Hotel, the regular room rate at that time was $129. I negotiated a $99 a night rate for my attendees. I got ZERO kickback of any kind! What I did get was a $5,000 a day ballroom for free if we booked enough rooms. If the bookings fell short, I would have to make up the balance at the going rate of $99 a night for however many nights it took. The hotel put a hold on my credit card for $10,000! And that my friends is the name of that tune.

Casino hotels are entirely different as I said before. At the Sands in Reno, I got the ballroom free as part of the deal, no guarantee required. With them I negotiated a room rate of $29/nite for a single and $39 for a double room. This was in line with the best prices they offer online during a slow season. I needed to book a total of 800 room nights to get a kickback. If it fell short I got nothing, but if it went over I got $5 per room night. That was a big bonus for me if I could bring enough people that would stay at the Sands. 800 room nights meant a $4,000 bonus! In the first few years I never quite made it, sometimes falling short by less than fifty room nights. Maybe in the fifth or sixth year I finally got over 800 room nights, so my event became a lot more lucrative for me as the promoter.

The above is an example of a good deal for the players and the promoter alike, and is somewhat typical of what usually happens at casino/hotels. I will go one step further in answering the OP's original question. At it's peak my net income for producing the U.S. Bar Table Championships was never much more than $10-15,000, with maybe the last two years close to the higher number. That, after six months of planning, probably the last three months working on it daily, and then a final tournament week of 12-14 hour days. I'm sure I could have made more money managing a MacDonalds.

It isn't easy to turn a profit running a pool tournament and my hat is off to the promoters who can do it. It took me years to figure out how to accomplish this and along the way I lost as much as 20K in one event! Nice job huh? :rolleyes:

Great insights on inner workings of running tourney. I would imagine in first few years that you missed the rooms quota by 50 rooms, you dished out your own money about $1500 to $2000 to pay for the 50 rooms so you can get bonus $4000
I am sure running your own tourney beats working as TD for other tourneys :grin:
 

Dagwoodz

the dude abides...
Silver Member
We have serious difference of opinion if you think 300 a hour is reasonable?

Nurses, doctors and lawyers don't make 300 a hour!

First pays 1k director gets 3k hours directly worked is 6 day one and 4 day two.

Its utter bs!

Kd
I know the three regional tours that I've played on, the TD's took in about 1500 for about 28-30 hours of work at the tournament and however many hours promoting the event in the weeks bulking up to it. Even if they only spend an average of 5 hours a week for 2 weeks leading up to it, that's 40 hours of work for 1500. (That's with a good turnout for the tournament.). A little over 40 an hour... Not the 300 an hour you are purporting. And that is before expenses.
 
Top