Just How Great is Efren Bata Reyes?

Ummm...Your conversion table is off just a TAD! LMAO 50,000 Yen is the U.S. equivilant of $500, not $20K! :eek: :D Somewhat the same for PI dollars to U.S. dollars...only it's about 10-1 I believe.

Scott Lee
www.poolknowledge.com

PROG8R said:
(are those amounts converted to US $$ or are they like wins that pay 50,000 yen and it is like 20,000 US?).
 
My sources told me that Efren (along with other Pinoy competitors) DID receive all their money from Trudeau...unlike all the American players.:mad:

Scott Lee
www.poolknowledge.com

RED NAXELA said:
Whether or not Efren got paid the full prize is a separate issue. The fact is he won it.
 
...and Greenleaf made WAY more $$$ than Mosconi could ever dream of (Mosconi's biggest payday EVER was the $60K he was paid to play Fats on tv...and that was only once). At his peak Greenleaf was earning $2000/week! :eek: In today's dollars that would be nearly $150,000-$200,000/week! Not bad dough for a poolplayer! :D You're correct about Greenleaf's era being the "heyday" of pool in America.

Scott Lee
www.poolknowledge.com

rossaroni said:
I think that Greenleaf's era may have been more of America's heyday for billiards, but I may be wrong. Either way, Greenleaf didn't do too bad himself either.
 
Scott Lee said:
...and Greenleaf made WAY more $$$ than Mosconi could ever dream of (Mosconi's biggest payday EVER was the $60K he was paid to play Fats on tv...and that was only once). At his peak Greenleaf was earning $2000/week! :eek: In today's dollars that would be nearly $150,000-$200,000/week! Not bad dough for a poolplayer! :D You're correct about Greenleaf's era being the "heyday" of pool in America.

Scott Lee
www.poolknowledge.com


scott i'm not picking on you but i dont think the value of a dolllar has gone up 75 to 100 times as you stated above, but your 100% right that he was making one hell of alot more $$$ than anyone is today. the main point is that the current champions are getting robbed by the condition of pool, when i started in 85 i thought it was bad, i couldnt imagine it was going to get worse.....sadly I was wrong. perhaps another depression will help pool, not sure thats a good thing but its a thought.
 
Fatboy said:
scott i'm not picking on you but i dont think the value of a dolllar has gone up 75 to 100 times as you stated above, but your 100% right that he was making one hell of alot more $$$ than anyone is today. the main point is that the current champions are getting robbed by the condition of pool...

Did some research and here's what I found:

Ralph Greenleaf was the world champion from 1919-1924 and intermittantly from 1926-1937.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (using the CPI as its base for calculations), $2000 in 1919 (the beginning of his reign) was worth $23,780 in 2007 dollars... in 1928, the midpoint of his dominance, the same $2000 was worth $24,058 in 2007 dollars... and at the end of his run in 1937, the same $2000 was worth $28,569 dollars.

Using the average of $26,175 for the period covered, if Ralph truly was making $2000 per week, then he was making $1.36M per year (in 2007 dollars) over that 19 year period... not too shabby! :rolleyes: ;)
 
cigardave said:
... if Ralph truly was making $2000 per week, then he was making $1.36M per year (in 2007 dollars) over that 19 year period... not too shabby! :rolleyes: ;)
I doubt that he was making anywhere near that much. Where did the $100,000 per year come from?

There is a story of Greenleaf earning great sums in Vaudeville, but Cue Ball Kelly said that the "shoot trick shots on a stage with mirrors" gig lasted about a week.
 
I am happy to see that the anitokid is so proud of his fellow countryman.His sincere admiration of Efein is as refreshing as his politness and humility, which I find easier to admire than to emulate.

As a well known easy mark,I have helped many great players make expenses when I mistakingly thought I had the nuts.

Among those many players I know I have never met one who would play Efrin without a large handicap or a careless stakehorse.

Comparing Mosconi to Efren?But I don't believe any one pocket player could even come close.
 
Bob Jewett said:
I doubt that he was making anywhere near that much. Where did the $100,000 per year come from?
It comes from pool talk Bob. The stories grow in the telling. Just do the sums. Before television revenue you only got your cut of the gate money. How many people attended these exhibitions and what did they pay? Not that much I would expect.

Boro Nut
 
JoeyInCali said:
The Efren I saw in the early mid-90's was as good as anyone in history imo.

Possibly the best "who's best of all time" statement made here. But my vote? Mosconi. Kind of like when Dad & I would argue about Ali vs. Joe Lewis. We'll never know, but the debate will go on for a long time...
 
kgeorgia said:
Ok people...are hearing what you are saying? MiKe Siegel: Huge player....collapsed after 50 years old... Earl Strickland: Huge player....Where is he now?... Nick Varner: Huge player... no news as well... My point is that these 3 american players, among many others great players of history, had their cycle and gave to the sport what they had to give: PRESTIGE. Efren Reyes is something else. It is a phenomenon. For 30+ years now, dominates the sport and million of peoples around the globe have been tought playing good pool simply by watching him through videos. And always remember: carom billiards is the father and the mother of pool...whoever plays good carom, he knows how to play pool...the little white spots on table that many of you ignore their existence -the diamonds- play a significant role of how you gonna play excellent pool. Efren Reyes is an excellent carom player as well. Remember that Efren Reyes never touched a jump cue in his life...fancy in billiards is the artistic way of playing, the orthodox playing not jumping like a frog. Like it or not, Efren Reyes is a living legend and noone has the right to say the oppposite. That is what i have to say. I know that american people will hate me but i just wanted to say what i believed...One last thing. I read a post about Earl's father's death. My truly condolenses to him and to his family.
I'm an American and I sure don't hate you. I think most Americans would agree with your assessment. I think a lot of the negative is being said in jest. It's the American way. Philw
 
PROG8R said:
I would have to give him credit that his best is probably better than about anyone elses best, but at that level, what does that mean? I dont know if there is a record for most racks ran but I do know that there is one for most balls ran is straight pool and he doesn't own that. I dont even know what his high run is; does anyone have that info? I dont think he owns more world titles or US open titles than anyone else, but there is a reason that many players stay clear of him. I just wish I had some of that reason on film so I could watch it. He was apparently at his best before I got into pool (maybe before I could walk). I feel left out missing what skill caused such stories. I can only compare him to what I see now adays and that is (this is just a guess) 2 wins in the last 5 years or so? In 13 years kids are going to hear how great Tiger is and besides all the super man stories there will be film for them to see it. I sure would like to see some of the comparable footage of the Great Efren. You know you got game when such a high percentage of pros list you as their favorite (considering most pros are fairly self centered when it comes to playing).
I'll give you an example. Pick your favorite player. Got him thunk out? Good. Now..... flash back twenty years. Efren could give him the seven, or 8-6, or thirty to a hundred and bet every last penny he's got. Make sense? Ask every one of them who scared them the most when he got to the states and got "known."
 
crawfish said:
I'll give you an example. Pick your favorite player. Got him thunk out? Good. Now..... flash back twenty years. Efren could give him the seven, or 8-6, or thirty to a hundred and bet every last penny he's got. Make sense? Ask every one of them who scared them the most when he got to the states and got "known."


Hard to imagine anyone spotting Dallas West, Irving Crane, Willi Mosconi 30 balls and beating them.
 
Scott Lee said:
...and Greenleaf made WAY more $$$ than Mosconi could ever dream of (Mosconi's biggest payday EVER was the $60K he was paid to play Fats on tv...and that was only once). At his peak Greenleaf was earning $2000/week! :eek: In today's dollars that would be nearly $150,000-$200,000/week! Not bad dough for a poolplayer! :D You're correct about Greenleaf's era being the "heyday" of pool in America.

Scott Lee
www.poolknowledge.com

Scott, I'm not entirely sure of that. Willie started out on his famous tour with Greenleaf at only $150 per week when Willie was only 20 or 21. But that tour lasted only 112 days...brutal as they were.

After that, though, Sylvester Livingston offered and Willie accepted a solo tour for which Willie got 75% of the proceeds!

He was on that tour virtually non-stop for 8 years and willie was quoted as saying that he sometimes did 4 nearby cities/towns in a single day.

I don't know how many stops a year he did but I don't think that 350 would be an excessive number. So, if the GROSS on each stop was only $500 and he got 75% of that, he would have made $375 per stop x 350 stops =$131,250 or around $2500 per week.

And one thing's for SURE...Willie's bar tab was ZERO and Greanleaf's could have funded the National Debt so on a NET basis, it seems to me that Willie would have been WAY ahead.

Just guessing.

Regards,
Jim
 
Bob Jewett said:
Was he better than Harold Worst?
Prolly not better.
But, if you are talking one pocket, Efren wins.
Nine-ball? Efren was shooting in the 900's in some tournaments iirc.
I know when he won at The Bike, he shot in the .900's for the tournament.
He did at Reds too iirc in his first appearance here.
But, HW would have been better at straight pool and 3c of course.
 
rossaroni said:
I think that Greenleaf's era may have been more of America's heyday for billiards, but I may be wrong. Either way, Greenleaf didn't do too bad himself either.

Come to think of it...you're right but the 1930s and 40s were HUGE compared to today.

Thanks for correcting me though.

Regards,
Jim
 
rossaroni said:
Willie did dominate in his era more then Reyes, but... First off, I believe most of Mosconi's championships used a round robin format. You know that the better player will do better with this format. One bad match will not cost you the tourney. Also, many of the "championships" in 14.1 were ,in reality, challenge matches between two players. I think Efren would have won many more championships in his career if he only had to play one opponent over a long period of time. Lastly, 14.1 has a much less luck factor then 9-ball. Amongst the top players, certain tournaments are won by the person who breaks the best. One pocket also has much less of a luck factor then 9-ball and see how Efren has done playing that game. He has not done too bad playing 8-ball either!

Plus Efren is nicer then Willie! :D


Yeah but Ghengis Kahn was nicer that Willie! (-:

He had a ROUGH go as a kid though.

Regards,
Jim
 
Bob Jewett said:
I doubt that he was making anywhere near that much. Where did the $100,000 per year come from?

There is a story of Greenleaf earning great sums in Vaudeville, but Cue Ball Kelly said that the "shoot trick shots on a stage with mirrors" gig lasted about a week.

And even if he was making 2 grand per week, you can only count the weeks when he was able to remain conscious most of the time...which certainly was not 52 per year.

Regards,
Jim
 
Back
Top