Count me in for one who believes the TD should be able to really lay down the law and stop this type of thing. In fact, I think it should be in the TD's job description.... "if any player is getting very out of hand, it will reflect poorly on you (the TD)." Once the TD's lay it down a time or two (loss of match, loss of game, whatever).... the player's will wise up quick. It truly is simple if you ask me.... give the TD responsibility for the comportment of the players, and give him the power to "lay down the law" (and perhaps a raise).
I hold the opposite viewpoint. This is something that people will tune in to watch on cable tv.
You see, people were enamored with John McEnroe and Jimmy Connors. Just to see what they would do next. And in our sport, the player that draws the most attention is Earl Strickland. And he is 50 years old now, and other players have caught up with his skill. Why do you think Earl has the strongest following?
People want to see action. People tune in to the controversial players. The average pool viewer on cable tv wants to see the players jumping and screaming, not sitting in the chair quietly.
If Nevel did this during an ESPN match, it would have made Sportscenter. And a few new people would start to enjoy the game.
When you go to a hockey game and there are 5 fights, listen to what people are talking about when you exit the arena. They are all talking about the fights.
Pool doesn't have to be all about the details on the table. Not every fan gets into the precision of the game. I watch football on Sunday, but I am not concerned with the offensive linemen's footwork. But a friend of mine who used to play notices things like that.
So, it is entertainment. Did you go to Valley Forge last time? Earl got kicked out by the TD. The few fans that were in attendance came to see him play. They might have even came to see him throw a tantrum, or do something spectacular.
So if Nevel wants to become unruly at the table, by all means let him!