Since my name is being bandied about here, along with Earl's, I'll put in my two cents. FWIW, if you don't have a GREAT set up and delivery system for your cuestick (read: accurate, repeatable and sustainable stroke) already in place, then all the lessons in the world from the best pros on Earth will not help you all that much. That said, I believe that getting lessons from Earl would be a BARGAIN at $75/hr. He could charge twice that much, and it would STILL be a bargain! His knowledge of how to PLAY is unsurpassed, and I'm sure that a good player would definitely have the opportunity to gain some insights into becoming a much better player.
I will say this...when pro players come to instructors like Randy and myself they are looking for quirks in their stroke...not for knowledge of how to play better position or learn better patterns. Can we teach advanced players better shot selection, strategy, pattern play, and advanced techniques like jumps, banks and multiple rail kicks? Yes...but most advanced players still need work on their stroke. Are we "better" at that then Earl? I would say it depends a lot on the student. I personally believe someone who is serious about improving their pool game should take lessons from as many competent "teachers" (read: some pro players too) as they have the time and money to access. I know Earl personally, and I think I'd love lessons with him myself, and plan to take advantage of this the next time I'm down in SC! Great teachers continue learning from everyone they can! One more thing...this can only make Earl an even BETTER pro player, and I hope he makes a comeback and wins more world championships! I'll be cheering him on all the way!
Scott Lee
www.poolknowledge.com