I read it. Nothing is new. Please don't suggest I didn't read "it." Of all the posters on this ridiculous topics, I've read more than most. You need to go reread all of his posts.. I don't need to.Actually, he gave very good advice. Maybe you should re-read what he wrote. ?? He never stated that one shouldn't use spin. And, I think that if you re-read it, you will find that you essentially said the same thing he did.
I totally agree with teaching center axis first. There is a good reason for this. If you can't hit center axis reliably, you will never be able to hit anywhere else reliably either. Which means, you will never attain the repeat ability and consistency that you are capable of achieving.
Learn what center axis can do for you. Learn what the different speeds can and will do for you. Learn the 30 degree , the 90 degree, the 45 degree rules. Learn the 1/2 rule for draw. Then get into english. Learn the clock system. Learn what different speeds do with english. Learn what english does to the speed of the cb off rails. Learn to use all the way out on the cb. Learn to partial masse' and full masse'.
I'd say about half my shots are center axis. Then about 45% of the rest are about one tip of spin. Rarely do I need to go farther out on the cb. Although it does come up now and then.
English is a big killer of consistency in both shot making and position play with amateurs. Is it needed? Of course it is. You will never attain your top speed without full control of the cb. At the same time, with amateurs, I believe it is way overused. You will stay more consistent when you can stay closer to the center axis than when you are usually seeing how much spin you can get because it looks flashy.
Freddie <~~~ must be a rookie