What Do you think would be a fair game?

All these opinions and the most important variable was barely discussed, the equipment. think before posting. ;) :)


on a bar box giving up the 8 and the pop to a A- player who is a barbox player is tough action.


on a 9' Diamond the 8 and the break, JS is going to make a easy score.

I agree with this. But getting the break is the big spot. If you know how to make the wing or the 1 on the break and controling the QB for a shot you have a good chance on the BB. Johnnyt
 
Id probably try the 7 or 8 and the breaks on a bar table or maybe either the 6 or the 7 out and the breaks on a big table. Im not quite sure how i rank but id think probably an A. Thats wat i think id be comfortable with, but as good as he plays who knows. If he caught a gear that might not be nearly enough
 
Come on now I watched SVB destroy an A player giving the 6&8 last 4 and the breaks. Yes he SVB won the race by 3 or 4 games if I remember correctly. Yes the other guy played good. He literally lost by the couple dry breaks, having to push out, or tied up balls. Maybe missed 1 or 2 open shots but that is it. He didn't dog it, he played a damn champion.

I'm thinking the 5 and the last 5 with all the snaps is a decent starting point, and thats just a starting point. You probably will need more.
 
Johnnyt,

If you are realistically a B player, and not an A, then the 8 and the breaks would not be enough.

Figure it this way.. If you break and don't make a ball, you lose.

If you break and make a ball, but are hooked on the 1.. You lose.

If you have to play a safety, and don't leave it nearly frozen to the object ball, he kicks and either makes it on a multiway shot, or kicks and resafes you, better than you safed him. You prolly lose outright on this about 65% of the time if you play a weak safety.

If you miss the safety, whether or not you leave a shot, you lose.

So, all in all.. If you are not breaking and running out MINIMUM 40% of the time, the break ain't worth a lot. If you are, then you are not a B player..You are a solid A player.

Russ

You are right. I'm thinking on my Valley BB where I can beat the ghost race to 9 w/o BIH about 35% of the time. With the wild 8 it should put me at close to 45% of the time. I'll try it today when it warms up outside. Now that I have the "Ridgeback Rails" by therealkingcobra on it I might not be able to do it anymore. The pocket angles are cut different and don't cheat as well as they use to with the standard rails. Johnnyt
 
What do think you would need in a race to 11 playing 9-ball against a pro like John Schmidt for $100 or more a set?

Please the rating you feel you are also....A, B, C, D. I'm a "B" on a BB. I believe I would need the wild 8 and the breaks. Johnnyt

that doesn't sound like enough for a "B" player to win with
 
i would want the 6 out and the breaks, and 2 games on the wire, i would try that for 100 bucks it would be worth the experiance
 
On the bar table playing a pro I would take the 5 and the snaps in 9 ball, they cant put packages together and I might actually put stuff together only having to run to the 5. :cool:
 
Come on now I watched SVB destroy an A player giving the 6&8 last 4 and the breaks. Yes he SVB won the race by 3 or 4 games if I remember correctly. Yes the other guy played good. He literally lost by the couple dry breaks, having to push out, or tied up balls. Maybe missed 1 or 2 open shots but that is it. He didn't dog it, he played a damn champion.

I'm thinking the 5 and the last 5 with all the snaps is a decent starting point, and thats just a starting point. You probably will need more.
Im no great player by any means but if you're talkin about a barbox, i dont think anyone on gods green earth can give me the 5 the last 5 and the breaks. I think my break is too strong, unless they try to gaff me every rack which ill see and stop. If i was playin someone like shane id want somethin like the 3 out if i couldnt get the breaks and probably still lose. The break is a huge spot on a barbox but you're also talkin about the 5 and the last 5, thats a ridiculous spot that i dont think anyone would be smart to give a strong player.
 
Many great replies here. The one big variable i think is not too many people have seen a top champ play a "B" player for anything substantial $$$. We always see top pros playing each other, so the variables are generally equal. I've watched Champions play "A" and "B" playrs and I remember sitting there saying.....theres not enough weight on the planet! :)

Especially in a long set 11 or more games.....the damn %'s are the killer for the lesser player. If I had to play a top pro....I'd want short sets, the break, and all the luck!

G.
 
I think the big problem here would be getting JS to play for only $100. For $100, he might walk over to the table and talk about playing . If by some chance he would play for only $100 a set, I would play him at the US BB Championship in FEB. I would be willing to play a few races of 9 ball to 9 for $100 with the 7 ball and breaks.
 
The main thing would be getting the break. Not because I feel my break or anyone else is that good. But it keeps JS or who ever from getting multiple packages without having an opportunity at the table. I'm not trying to knock anyone's ability just being realistic about the pro's ability. The break is huge and prob worth a couple of balls or more.
 
The main thing would be getting the break. Not because I feel my break or anyone else is that good. But it keeps JS or who ever from getting multiple packages without having an opportunity at the table. I'm not trying to knock anyone's ability just being realistic about the pro's ability. The break is huge and prob worth a couple of balls or more.

I've played a few Pro Players cheap with the breaks and the call 7 and 8 .... back when I was playing a lot. I always won or broke even, but never won much! LOL Most of them you ask won't even consider giving anyone that can play a little a spot like that, if they're smart.

Since I don't play that much anymore, I probably wouldn't like it..... but I'd still play cheap just for the experience. Normally I don't even like to get a spot.... I just lose what I can afford and quit if I have no chance to win. Then if my opponent offers me some weight, I might play a few more sets .... but I don't ask for weight very often unless he's a top player.

For any of us "lowly" bangers, you have to have to get the Breaks for sure...
plus a ball or 2........ to have any kind of a chance against a top player.


IMHO
 
Well I played the first set of "the ghost" w/o BIH and getting the wild 8. I racked the 8 in back of the rack. 11- 9 ghost won. I made a combo on the 8 once, the 9 once, and 9 on the snap once. Break was not good for most of this set. I'll play 2 more sets later. I'll get him at least one set lol. This was on a Valley BB. Johnnyt
 
Knocking thread.

If you guys are serious about playing John, you should PM him your contact information so that when he is in your town or you are at the tournament together, he can make a decision to play you or not.

He may want your "real name" so be prepared to give it. He uses his real name.

I wouldn't play John on a bar box period. I don't like them but one day I may come to like them. For right now, it's tight 9 footers for me. Besides a reasonable spot, I would want him to hang up his OB cue and play with a house cue. lol

Way back when, this thread would be called a KNOCKING THREAD. :-)
JoeyA
 
What do think you would need in a race to 11 playing 9-ball against a pro like John Schmidt for $100 or more a set?

Please the rating you feel you are also....A, B, C, D. I'm a "B" on a BB. I believe I would need the wild 8 and the breaks. Johnnyt

The Break and any ball,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,We would have a lot of fun.
 
If you guys are serious about playing John, you should PM him your contact information so that when he is in your town or you are at the tournament together, he can make a decision to play you or not.

He may want your "real name" so be prepared to give it. He uses his real name.

I wouldn't play John on a bar box period. I don't like them but one day I may come to like them. For right now, it's tight 9 footers for me. Besides a reasonable spot, I would want him to hang up his OB cue and play with a house cue. lol

Way back when, this thread would be called a KNOCKING THREAD. :-)
JoeyA

How do you figure I'm knocking John? I just used his name as "a pro like John S." meaning ANY pro that shoots around his speed. The last thing I would do is knock John on here or in person. I have too much respect for him. John Terrell
 
How do you figure I'm knocking John? I just used his name as "a pro like John S." meaning ANY pro that shoots around his speed. The last thing I would do is knock John on here or in person. I have too much respect for him. John Terrell

John, I think the Internet and other technology have put player's level of play in the street.

In the pool room I "grew up in", you had to be very close to someone to get them to tell you the speed of another player or that information would be provided to you if the other person was part of your corporation. That was about it. It was every man for himself. Any freely shared information about a players speed was considered knocking and was frowned upon.

Now, with measurements of speed down to almost a science, it is quite easy to acquire or read the information that is shared and posted freely on forums just like this everyday. These days this information is shared freely even amongst complete strangers. That wasn't the case in the old days.

In the old days, the road players received information about potential scores from past experiences and other road players so they had their source of information even back then but that wasn't called knocking even back then. :grin: Some of the players kept little black books detailing the speeds of potential customers in different cities and that information would be shared only with other people who had similar information.

I think the days of "knocking someone's action" are over. Yeah, I think technology has just allowed knocking to "move on", as Stephen King once said in one of his books about the world "moving on". Instead of just the chosen few (the road players) having inside information about other players' speeds, now anyone with a computer or a cell phone can get all of the information they need about how someone plays and what kind of weight you will need to give or get. Sometimes the technology is so good and current, you can even tell how much money a player has in his pocket within 24 hours.

Knocking someone (acquiring information) was considered OK even back then if you provided the information "quietly" and only to one or two "in the know", without a large number of people knowing about it. Basically knocking was frowned upon by the gamblers by those who INDISCRIMINATELY shared a players speed without the remote chance of that person making a dollar. Nowadays, the world has just moved on and so has knocking. It's not the same anymore......

We all respect John and I know you didn't intend any harm by the thread or using his name. I am pretty sure no harm has been done. John doesn't gamble much with us bangers anyway and he's not out on the street trying to match up. So I am pretty sure that John isn't losing any sleep over guys that play our speed getting a line on him.

It is interesting though, that the spots suggested range from very conservative to very liberal.

JoeyA
 
Joey,

I didn't actually say what i think a B player "needs", only gave an analysis of why what they would ask for would not be nearly enough.

I am curious though.. How"helpful" would you say the information i have given in this thread is? I would like to say i am pretty good at clocking speeds, and identifying what weak/strong points are in others (and my own) games.

You never know though... I might be mistaken on a lot of concepts myself.. :D

Russ
 
Back
Top