I don't think my Revo hit any better or worse than any 314/Z shafts I've had the prior 20 years, it plays exactly the same to me. But I've had it 5 years now, and there is not an even a hint of a ding, scratch, or wear on it. I can't say the same for any 314/Z or wood butt I've every had, which all get battle scars no matter how careful I am.
I'm not looking for a magic hit with a CF butt. I think a plain butt with nothing on it would sell like hot cakes, if made by one of the Chinese companies and priced at $100 or less for the butt only. There are plenty of CF shafts now that are very nice quality for less than $100. The Crical complete cue with wood butt and a very nice CF shaft is $130 total. If one of those companies used the exact same material and construction technique on the butt that they do on the shaft, sign me right up.
We could probably leave in the car year round, bang it around. No finish to chip. Nothing to warp. Etc. And from what we've seen of the CF shafts, they'd be straighter than the wood butts when new, and definitely straighter over the long term.
Some company is missing a big opportunity IMO.