John the ones I have seen that were advertised in the earlier Brunswick catalogs from the Mid-1950's back, were made very nice, the stitching was good and well done and the leather was thick, and this is exactly how you identify the earlier Brunswick cases from the Crap made later. The problem I see is that the standard design was carried into the 1960's when the quality began to suffer, those that were Leather at all were flimsy on a cardboard frame. Finally toward the end of the 1960's there was no Leather in cases at all just a cheap vinyl over Cardboard.
I think that since more of the Cheap (Most Likely) imports have survived because they are not as old, many people mistake these cases for higher quality cases that were made by Brunswick in the past.
I have most of Brunswick's Catalogs from 1915 to date and I also have some that are older.
In closing the Brunswick company of today is no help, much of their documentation either was thrown away or lost. This is a major problem when trying to identify Brunswick cues and cases from the 1950's back.
Based upon research I have done on this subject.
Good info once again Craig.
It may bear mentioning once again that pool/billiard equment for sale
prior to the boom launched by "The Hustler" was, mostly, low in price
and high in quality. All the reasons for that situation would be a very
long discussion indeed. But mostly it was because the biz of pool was
at a VERY low ebb.
IMHO - you must keep in mind, in those days, people just simply did
not have the emotional investment in the 'tools of the trade' like so
many do today. Perhaps a '63 Corvette is "sloppy" compared to a 2003
model - but I sure wouldn't mind having one.
Dale