I have won a car or two (including a 1969 Caddy conv.), TV's, all kinds of jewelry, several cues and even a big ass Harley once. But the one that got me was when I beat a guy for all his money and he put up his very nice McDermott cue against $100. It was in one of those slim McDermott cases. Well I won the cue and went to pay the time, while the guy put "my" new cue away.
After I paid, the guy is standing right there, his cue case in hand. He handed me the case, shook my hand and hit the door. I could feel that the case was full so I didn't worry about it. I assumed (stupid me) that the cue was inside. Heck, I had seen him putting the cue away. I took the case back to my apartment and opened it up. There was a broken broom stick inside! He had done a quick switch on me and I never noticed it. Never saw the guy again after that. At least I got the case, which I kept for years.