Rate These Cues

D

Dawgie

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Nitti - Blackcreek - Ed Prewitt - Ariel Carmeli(sp) - on a scale of 1 to 10 with #10 being the highest rating.

Sorry for the 2 posts.
 
Last edited:
I personally like my BlackCreek, but will also own a Nitti some day!!!!!!

cuepics016.jpg


Russ.....
 
I've never owned/played with any of these four... but if I had a "want" list they would be in this order:

1. Prewitt
2. Nitti
3. Blackcreek
4. Ariel Carmeli
 
Yep

Charlie Edwards said:
I've never owned/played with any of these four... but if I had a "want" list they would be in this order:

1. Prewitt
2. Nitti
3. Blackcreek
4. Ariel Carmeli
Click to expand...


I agree with Charlie....

Ken
 
Charlie Edwards said:
I've never owned/played with any of these four... but if I had a "want" list they would be in this order:

1. Prewitt
2. Nitti
3. Blackcreek
4. Ariel Carmeli
Click to expand...

I've got to agree with Charlie, too!

Steve
 
Charlie Edwards said:
I've never owned/played with any of these four... but if I had a "want" list they would be in this order:

1. Prewitt
2. Nitti
3. Blackcreek
4. Ariel Carmeli
Click to expand...


Same order for me...
Joe
 
Thanks for the replies. I value your opinions. Many of the posters on this site are very knowledgable and your input is appreciated. I am going to save this thread to my favorites.
 
Prewitt
Blackcreek
Nitti
Carmelli

Just My 2 Cents

I RATED BASED ON BUILD QUALITY, COLLECTIBILITY, AND LONG TERM VALUE(MY OPINION OF VALUE)
 
Last edited:
Never hit with any of the four, but if I had to rate, I would go exactly with Fast-n-loose. This is just by what I've read here, and my opinion only.
 
im all about the carmelis. granted i've never tried a prewitt or a nitti but people say nittis are somewhat soft so i doubt i'd like it at all. the carmeli is perfect for me cuz its so stiff.

i've tried other stuff like ginacue, southwest etc. i've never found anything that's come close to replacing my carmeli yet. hopefully the searing i get in the future will replace it.
 
FAST_N_LOOSE said:
Prewitt
Blackcreek
Nitti
Carmelli

Just My 2 Cents

I RATED BASED ON BUILD QUALITY, COLLECTIBILITY, AND LONG TERM VALUE(MY OPINION OF VALUE)
Click to expand...


I agree.....might even have Nitti and Travis tied in second place. All three makers build fine cues, no doubt. Prewitt's work is virtually flawless from what I have seen. His workmanship is arguably as good if not better than many of the BIG NAME (hof) makers.....but collectibility and resale is more dubious than some of the hof makers. Collectibility/resaleability on the others tends to vary more with the design and materials used.
 
I also agree with Marcus's assessment, but the one aspect that seems to have been left out of this thread is...

A Prewitt with the same amount if inlays is going to cost at least twice as much as the same cue from any of the other 3 makers.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top