jay helfert said:
First day pbservations.
The refs are racking the balls by hand, on pre-dented tables. UGH! It just goes against everything Ive learned the last 30-40 years. the roll of a slow moving ball absolutely could be affected by the dents in the cloth. There are perfectly good Brunswick racks under each table. Why not use them? I KNOW I can put a better rack up there using a good rack then anyone can using their bare hands!!
I am watching refs roll balls into place a few at a time. A tight rack? No way! The only rack you can put up fairly tight with your hands is Six Ball. Interestingly most players don't seem to mind. I would have thought there would be an uproar. The Brunswick Gold Crowns V's are beautiful table's. They just need to be releveled, still a lot of roll offs.
The rules here are also new. It is "call shot" Ten Ball, and you must make the ball you call. No "two way" shots here. Other rules are quite confusing to me. There are several instances where your opponent can make you shoot again. Not just on a push out. Too many rules and it can be confusing for some players. You can call safe and make a ball. It's now your oppnent's turn. They have taken a great game like Ten Ball and made it look like Eight Ball. Who's responsible for this I don't know. I can only guess. :wink:
The matches now become strategic battles in many instances. Perhaps they play this way in Europe, advantage Eurotour players!
At least you can win on the break and the winner gets to break the next game.
I agree with some of what you say Jay, I too have seen things which I don't like.
One thing is certain, Matchroom Sport have nothing to fear from this organisation, it is a bit shoddy in comparison to what we are used to.
I don't know who is calling the shots here, but they should have learned more from the "English Professionals" who were responsible for the last two years's tournaments.
With regard to tapping the tables, if we had to rely on the refs to rack, the matches would take much longer to complete (and some of them are already taking up the complete two hours allowed as there is quite a lot of safety play) since there would inevitably be arguments from the players over the racking. The tapping mat used does give a tight rack, that has been proved in Europe over the past couple of years.
This is call shot and if a player pots the ball in the wrong pocket and ends up hooking his opponent this gives him an unfair advantage so I consider the rule which allows the incoming player to refuse the shot, the correct one.
There are too many lucky shots in 9 ball for my liking and the way the ten ball is being played is much fairer.
I think you are wrong about the "safe shot", you may call a safe (not sure why you have to) but if you accidentally pot the ball, the opponent has the right to accept the position or hand it back. I don't see too much of a problem with that.
However it does seem to be an unneccesary rule.