Efren is still probably the best player that ever lived, although I think that distinction will one day belong to Filler. Sigel is the best ever American player in my books. He was one of the five best ever at 9ball during the 9ball era and was one of the five best ever at straight pool during the straight pool era. Mosconi and Greenleaf each have 15+ World Championships and dominated their respective eras in ways that we haven't seen since. They are the cornerstones, the foundational players upon which American pool was built. SVB, to me, is just the fourth best ever American.
Finally, the case for SVB over Filler would be a very weak one indeed. Still in his 20s, Filler has already won, at least once, each of the World 9-ball, the World Games gold medal, the UK Open, the US Open 9ball, the China Open 9ball, the World 8-ball, the Qatar World Cup 10ball, the European Open 9ball, the European 14.1, the Las Vegas Open 10ball, the Bali 10ball, the American 14.1, the Derby City 9ball, the Derby City banks, the Derby City Master of the Table, the Buffalo Billiards one-pocket, the World Pool Masters, and the World Cup of Pool. He also has double digit Euro-tour titles and has won both a silver and a bronze at the World 10ball. He has a WPA World Teams gold medal on his resume, too. No, Shane has not won everything and is missing several of the game's biggest titles on his resume. The same cannot be said of Filler, who seemingly gets around to winning every major title there is. Also, Filler has mass-produced major titles in all three of the major pool-playing continents while most of Shane's titles came on his home soil.
SVB is awesome, a living legend. I am very proud to say that I watched his unforgettable career up close over the years. I am proud to say that I was often there to congratulate him when he won his biggest titles and that I was there for his BCA Hall of Fame indcution.. His greatness is indisputable and his name rightly comes up when we speak of the best ever pool players ..... but cracking the top five of all time isn't easy, and I hope I made it clear why I chose the ones I did.