I most likely replace between 50 and 100 tips a month for my customers, and what I have come to believe is that tips just like anything else are nothing but a tool, some people have mentally convinced themselves that only certain tips will work and other don't have this hang up.
While it is important to have a tip that will hold it's shape, and hold chalk if proper maintenance is done, for there on it is up to the operator, and the operator's ability stroke through the cue ball properly.
I have people who have to buy every new tip that comes out, and that are never happy with the tips performance, in my opinion they need to work on their fundamentals not continue to buy new tips.
I can personally play with any tip I have ever encountered, so long as it holds shape and holds chalk, I also have the ability to install any tip made because i keep them all in stock. However, I use a non-layered tip and what many would consider a cheap tip ( Pressed Le Pro ) with which I can do anything that some one else can with any tip they use.
I think far to many people forget when it comes to any equipment or tool used, the performance the player gets from that equipment or tool is based upon that persons ability not some magic created by using the tool.
JIMO