What ABP is doing is a form of a strike.
No it isn't. ABP members are not employees of those who promote pool events. They have no obligation to participate in anybody's event, and, through their often unruly behavior and poor attire during events, they have shown event promoters time and time again that they feel no obligation to them or to the image of the sport which they are asking promoters to sell to the sponsors and fans.
ABP is a product, plain and simple. It is a product that, according to the ABP guidelines costs $25,000 (the added money minimum indicated). It is a very good product, a product made available for purchase to pool promoters who must determine what their business model for a potential event will look like if they buy it. Intentionally oversimplifying things, the promoter of a pool event has revenues derived from sponsorship and ticket sales, and its costs are production costs and added prize money. The ABP is a product that some pool promoters would choose to buy. Others would opt against such purchase because they do not foresee a profit if they pay this price.
It's really more simple than it looks. Not every pro pool player is making enough money to live at the moment, which let's face it, is unfair.
No it isn't. If you produce income for a business proprietor, you get paid. Being the best at something doesn't guarantee you anything unless the skill you have will allow others to generate income from it. What's unfair, or perhaps "unwise" is more accurate, is demanding so much money that proprietors rarely find a chance to profit by employing you and your services, which ultimately makes you less worthy of their pursuit. Recent history shows that pool promoters are struggling to make ends meet, even the most prominent of them. Some of them have or are about to split from the pool scene. I don't hear you weeping for them, despite the fact that ABP's pricing of its product is at odds with the realities of pool's current revenue picture to the point that pool's business model may start to crumble in America.
Everything ABP has stated in its guidelines is about making money out of the game. Seeding takes the draw factor out of the table, and so are call shots. Minimum added fees give the players more decent payouts. What they are trying to do is make more pros get paid. Why is this bad? That's why they are called pros anyway. Why is it bad to help out more people who have been playing pool for their entire lives and are talented enough to win major events?
Absolutely not the case. The guidelines are self-serving and do not address much of what the fans care about or what the promoters care about. I've attended about 500 pool events in dozens of cities in my life, and I can offer two generalizations. First, nothing gets the crowd more excited than a golden break, but the golden beak is eliminated by the rules demanded by ABP. Second, nothing upsets the crowd more than slow play. I have left more than a few events in my day prior to completion because the matches dragged on forever and ever, resulting in finals that began after midnight. I don't see anything in the ABP guidelines about the use of the shot clock, which serves the interests of both fans and promoters, both beneficiaries when tournaments run on schedule.
Finally, fans like to see pros excelling in a pool discipline with which they are familiar. Each rule change that makes the game less recognizable to the more mainstream amateur players serves to disenfranchise those players and make them care less and less about the pro game. Remarkably enough, the same pros that choose to disenfranchise the mainstream amateur player in this way are the ones who argue that amateur pool should somehow support pro pool. I could offer many other examples but won't bother, but take note of the fact that the ABP guidelines are meant to serve the players, not anyone else.
Like the ABP, I dream of the day when pro pool generates the kind of revenue that will justify a lot of added money. Still, ask any marketing executive --- when a product isn't selling is not the time to raise its price. Right now, pro pool is a product that isn't selling very well in America, and that's why added moneys are just about where they were in the 1980's. By mandating a high price for the pro pool product, the ABP is not only dictating policy to the promoters, but dictating poor policy at that. Players and promoters and possibly even fans need to sit down together and map out an approach to selling pool. Unfortunately, the players of ABP don't see it that way, and, as we've seen in this thread, the promoters and fans are shocked by it.