Earl tossed out of SBE...

I wasn't there, so won't comment about this incident.
I was there last year on the final day, though. The TD's behaviour towards Jon Pinegar in the final match was a disgrace. He yelled at him (and I mean _yelled_) several times - little things like the rack being a micron high, or standing briefly to see if Shane could get through to a ball. They edited the audio out on the youtube/ustream video.

The only kind of tournament that guy should be directing is dog-fighting. He has just the right class for that.


This may come as a shock to some people but gambling takes place at pool tournaments. When I see somebody sharking a player which is exactly what that TD is doing, it makes me wonder.
 
Sounds like another bad case of OBNOXIOUS ASSHOLEISM!!! Maybe someone should see how his mannerism changes playing with a neck brace.
 
Someone tell me this.... When was the last tournament that Earl attended where he didn't cause friction? I will guess it was prior to 1998.....

The Derby....48 days ago.

Shane vs Earl in the finals of one pocket....GREAT match.
 
a highly volatile person who people flock to see because he might explode.

While that may very well be true, look at the late great Evil Knevil.
Would it be fair to say that 50% of the fans went to see him make an impossible jump and 50% went to see the possibility of him not making it.

OK, maybe a bad analogy, motorcycles and pool but its the best I could come up with.

Personally, I'm glad that Earl is making a come back and his game is as strong as ever before. And sad at the same time that he is losing it again. I was truly hoping that, that part of him would be part of his past. If I ever get lucky enuff to see Earl play in the future, I will be there watching his game and not for any antics.

And if Alex was purposely sharking him by tilting the rack, then shame on him, and the TO for not letting Earl have his side of the story.
Thats something that would have been afforded to any other pro player.
 
Last edited:
I agree althoug I always thought that sharking ended up with some sort of foul like BIH or loss of game (not match). Someone correct me if Im wrong.

I believe that a lot of what would be considered sharking would fall under the category of unsportsmanlike conduct. This being the case, penalties can include anything up to and including being tossed from the event and is at the discretion of the ref or TD.
 
Last edited:
This is exactly what happened !!! I dont know why or who is saying in this post about Earl asked politly where his opponite is cause that didnt happen in the match I seen !! But everything the (KMRUNOUT) has posted is exactly what happened and the way I seen and heard it !! There are way to mant stories on here which never happened. <<ED
( I did learn one thing from this post ...not everything that is posted on here is true and some just post things just to post ! No matter if it's true or not !!

I wasnt commenting on his match with Alex, I wasnt there for that. But I was there for the match where he got ejected. Compare what ive said to the other thread in the forum where one az member actually talked to Earl and found out what really happened. Maybe you havent learned as much as you think you have from this post. Trust me im not posting to just be posting. I've been a member on az for almost 4 years now and this is my 17th post, so I think it's obvious that I dont feel the need to be heard that bad.
 
Last edited:
I was not there for that and thats definitely not acceptable. If he was gonnna take any actions he shouldve did it then is all im saying. We all know how Earl can be but you cant penalize him when he's not doing anything wrong regardless of his past. You cool with that?

sure man, I hear ya. That makes sense. I have never seen Frank or any other ref make an issue when the player was doing "nothing". I think Earl had sandpapered Frank's nerves for a while, was warned several times, and decided to push the issue. But I definitely see your point.

KMRUNOUT
 
If I remember right I think there was a thread last year right after the SBE about this Frank/TD guy. Maybe there is a pattern here with him.

I believe the pattern is that some pool players are disrespectful to their opponents and other players, and when they run into Frank, the BS is not tolerated. That is exactly what happened last year with Pinegar (and *no one* else), and this year with Earl (and no one else).

jmho,

KMRUNOUT
 
I wasnt commenting on his match with Alex, I wasnt there for that. But I was there for the match where he got ejected. Compare what ive said to the other thread in the forum where one az member actually talked to Earl and found out what really happened. Maybe you havent learned as much as you think you have from this post. Trust me im not posting to just be posting. I've been a member on az for almost 4 years now and this is my 17th post, so I think it's obvious that I dont feel the need to be heard that bad.


I guess the way I see it, the events *leading up to* the part that you did see are significant. You don't get a clean slate each time you play a new match, or each time a new spectator walks in. If someone tells you "if I hear a single word out of you again you are out", and you only witness the player saying one single word after, you might conclude that the TD was being unreasonable in ejecting him.

KMRUNOUT
 
They are both wrong.

The Earl should not be allowed to get away with his behavior and all players should have some level of respect for their colleagues as well as the people who paid good money to watch the pros. If he is out of line, make sure he understands it and give him his warnings.

On that note, Frank has no couth.
Anyone that has been around the past few years knows this about him.

Sure, he doesn't take any crap, but he loves playing the enforcer role too much.
He is just as rude as Earl could ever be, and just as hostile and is LOOKING for something to find flaw with so that he can raise his voice at. Believe me, if Earl didn't get yelled at, someone else most certainly would have.
You can bet on that.

It would have either been another player, someone in the stands who he thought made too much noise, or members of his own staff.
He is primed and ready to OVERREACT and flip out unnecessarily simply because his ego is too large to be impartial, and that is not a quality one wants in a TD.

If what people are saying here is true, that he failed to toss Earl when he was playing Alex, and that he subsequently came in the booth saying he was going to throw Earl out the next match, when at that point, Earl didn't display any behavior warranting being thrown out during the next match, that is just flat out wrong, any way you slice it.

At the very least, allow Earl to hang himself.
He most definitely will once he gets started. That is just a no brainer.
But don't make it personal, (which Frank did) and have a bone to pick with him. Once you do that, you are no longer impartial, and you really have no business being a TD from that point on.

This is the essence of Franks problem. He feel that by questioning his authority, that you are somehow questioning his manhood and he flips out.
Maybe this is due to having some level of limelight exposure when he was doing comedy that made him think he is more important then he is, but the fact of the matter is, he is there to serve.
Once his ego gets in the way, he is no longer able to do that objectively, and really should be replaced.

There is nothing wrong with running a tight ship. Players and spectators will appreciate that in the long run.
But there is no room at a professional event for egos to take center stage, and people need to understand that that goes for both Earl AND Frank.

Another awesom post,thank you sir!
 
I was sitting 10 feet from Earl during the match with Alex. Earl was doing his normal ranting, which was actually kind of funny. Some of his quotes were "Everyone thinks I'm the asshole. Well let me tell you, there are a LOT of assholes in this game. A LOT." About 10 seconds after that, Earl begins repeatedly smashing his shaft on the table. Frank said "Earl...Earl!!!" He almost had a pleading sorrowful tone to his voice. He rather politely told him that he couldn't abuse the equipment like that. He then more loudly and authoritatively told him "You're not the only one playing here. You are disrespecting the other players and I won't tolerate it. This is your final warning." Earl muttered something about not wanting to be here. So Frank said "so leave...you don't have to stay. Do you want to go?" Earl muttered something else, and Frank again said something like "ok, you want to leave now?" Earl basically said no I'll finish the match. So he did. The rack ended with Alex winning the match. Earl shook his hand, said something to Alex I couldn't hear. Alex chuckled. Earl walked out. About 10 minutes later, my friend comes into the pro arena and said that Earl was outside yelling and swearing. So this is a pro player swearing louding and making a scene at an even filled with amateurs and children (they have an under 14 bracket for crying out loud!). You think that promotes pool, or enhances the event? My guess is that him being ejected was a result of this, because I didn't see Earl again after that.

That's what I know.

KMRUNOUT

I was there also, up front directly in front of Earl's match and Shane's which was to his right. What KMRUNOUT says is true. Johnny was playing Charlie Williams on the table to Earl's left. Earl started getting worked up because the rack at his table was giving him trouble. He was right about this because Stevie Moore and his opponent played on the same table following Earl's match and they had trouble with it too. Then, when Earl got up to shoot he seemed to get annoyed when Archer walked behind him. That is when he started to go into his rant about a lot of assholes in pool and how he (Earl) wasn't one of them. Loud enough where everyone on my side of the bleachers could hear him including his fellow players. This caught the Frank's attention. Then Earl proceeded to slap the shaft of his stick loudly against the long rail by the side pocket 4 or 5 times. (Like a teacher would hit the podium to get the classes attention). This caused evryone to look in his direction. That is when the Frank and Earl had words. I like Earl as a player but this was certainly distracting his fellow players to the point where they were watching this during their own matches. Earl did eventually stop and his match went on. He lost to Alex, shook his hand, and left the arena. I do not know what happened in his next match. (at 8 pm)

As far as the previous comments about Allen and the SBE they are all uncalled for. I've been going to this event for many years and it is one of the most organized fan, player events out there. Allen does a great job! Frank does a very good job with the players and it's one of the best places to see the pros play up close. They do run a tight ship and expect the fans and players to conduct themselves properly, as should be. I have no issue with this, it keeps everyone coming back each year. I'ts one of the best shows out there.
 
I guess the way I see it, the events *leading up to* the part that you did see are significant. You don't get a clean slate each time you play a new match, or each time a new spectator walks in. If someone tells you "if I hear a single word out of you again you are out", and you only witness the player saying one single word after, you might conclude that the TD was being unreasonable in ejecting him.

KMRUNOUT

You're exactly right the events leading up to this would be very significant. I didnt realize that they had trouble earlier in the tournament and that he had been warned. But I dont think asking where your opponent is when he's 25 minutes late is really grounds for getting ejected. Thank you for seeing from my point of view though. I'm only commenting on what I seen thats all.
 
I'm kinda hesitant to post this. But the TD did Earl a favour. This is PA. We were all tought to respect our opponents and other players. Earl's shennanigans is the kind of thing that could set off someone from my area (Central PA). All it would take is a very inappropriate comment and/or action and Earl would get hurt. People from Central PA (and there are lots of them at SBE) are kind and respectful until someone acts like Earl. It is very possible someone coulda popped him one in the kisser. He has great abilities and that is not in dispute. However he has anger issues HE MUST ADDRESS!!!!

I do not see much of a future for him if he does not change. This damn well could set the precident that puts Earl on the sidelines for good. This I feel was a wakeup call. I hope he gets the help he needs.

Mark Shuman

Are you joking? You guys threw snowballs at Santa Claus. PA fans are the worst fans in every sport for every team. Sorry to hijack the thread, I just found this hilarious.
 
Meanwhile back at the Billiards Expo.....
 

Attachments

  • EarlSandwich.jpg
    EarlSandwich.jpg
    80 KB · Views: 554
So if you're not sure what actually happened and you were not even there, how can you defend him?

You misunderstand. I was not defending him when you posted this, I was just trying to find out what he did. I was asking why he got tossed. He did not get tossed during the Alex match. If his behavior was that bad in this match, he would have been thrown out on the spot. Didn't happen.
He says he got expelled because he asked why his opponent gets a phone call when hes 25mins late. This is what Earl says got him kicked out.
 
I believe that a lot of what would be considered sharking would fall under the category of unsportsmanlike conduct. This being the case, penalties can include anything up to and including being tossed from the event and is at the discretion of the ref or TD.

Thank you Dog
 
Back
Top