They are both wrong.
The Earl should not be allowed to get away with his behavior and all players should have some level of respect for their colleagues as well as the people who paid good money to watch the pros. If he is out of line, make sure he understands it and give him his warnings.
On that note, Frank has no couth.
Anyone that has been around the past few years knows this about him.
Sure, he doesn't take any crap, but he loves playing the enforcer role too much.
He is just as rude as Earl could ever be, and just as hostile and is LOOKING for something to find flaw with so that he can raise his voice at. Believe me, if Earl didn't get yelled at, someone else most certainly would have.
You can bet on that.
It would have either been another player, someone in the stands who he thought made too much noise, or members of his own staff.
He is primed and ready to OVERREACT and flip out unnecessarily simply because his ego is too large to be impartial, and that is not a quality one wants in a TD.
If what people are saying here is true, that he failed to toss Earl when he was playing Alex, and that he subsequently came in the booth saying he was going to throw Earl out the next match, when at that point, Earl didn't display any behavior warranting being thrown out during the next match, that is just flat out wrong, any way you slice it.
At the very least, allow Earl to hang himself.
He most definitely will once he gets started. That is just a no brainer.
But don't make it personal, (which Frank did) and have a bone to pick with him. Once you do that, you are no longer impartial, and you really have no business being a TD from that point on.
This is the essence of Franks problem. He feel that by questioning his authority, that you are somehow questioning his manhood and he flips out.
Maybe this is due to having some level of limelight exposure when he was doing comedy that made him think he is more important then he is, but the fact of the matter is, he is there to serve.
Once his ego gets in the way, he is no longer able to do that objectively, and really should be replaced.
There is nothing wrong with running a tight ship. Players and spectators will appreciate that in the long run.
But there is no room at a professional event for egos to take center stage, and people need to understand that that goes for both Earl AND Frank.