Rather than get hung up on cuemaker maybe you should consider trying different types of cues out. Wood to wood, steel jointed, LD shaft vs non, different balance points, different tapers, different weights. Alot of the hit differences in comparing cues could also come down to the tip and not the cue. I know that I dont like super hard tips myself and i find myself lacking confidence in their ability to hold chalk when i have to load it up to move whitey around.
After playing just under 30 years of pool, ive come to the conclusion that I prefer steel jointed cues that weigh around 19 to 19.5 oz with a ferrule that is around 12-12.5 mm. I also like a stiffer hitting cue. Falling under that specific type of cue, the best hitting ones ive owned were Szamboti, 60's/ early 70s Joss, Scruggs Titlist conversion. I just started trying out LD shafts but I find after two weeks of playing with them Im subject to missing any shot where I have to put english on the ball. I think that you can learn to play with either LD or no LD equally as well, but if your just learning the LD shaft might be easier for you to get a good handle on shots where there is alot of deflection involved. Like for example high inside to swing the cueball around three rails. That shot in particular from about 8 ft away is very difficult with my Szamboti but with a Predator Z2 bolted onto the gus I can hit the shot pretty reliably.