I disagree. Of the three, only Thorpe has even one high finish in WNT play. A much more reasonable view would be that none of them deserve to be selected.
You can be dogged at times, sjm. Very dogged! The only thing I agree with you with is the part I put in bold.
All three are over 30, and none represent the future of American pool. If Johan picked two young players instead of any of these, he'd have my fullest respect and I don't think America's chances would drop much, if any.
Like I said, dogged!
There is only one young U.S. player
actually eligible by WNT rules whose inclusion might not hurt so bad. Sam Henderson. He
might be able to hang with the big boys.
There are no others, as of now, sjm.
Fracasso-Verner would have fit, but he's hurt. Nathan Childress would be the next-best option, but he's a big step down from Bergman-Woodward-Thorpe. Payne McBride? Nope. He's not even on the WNT rankings list for U.S players. Shane Wolford? Hasn't played in enough events to be eligible. Nor has any other young player not listed here.